Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
ber of Philosophy East and West contains two articles referring to Zen thought. They come from the learned pens of university professors: Dr. H. E. McCarthy of Honolulu and Dr. Van Meter Ames of Cincinnati.1 The former interprets Goethe's Faust in the spirit of Zen, whereas the latter discusses Zen in reference to pragmatism and existentialism. Dr. McCarthy's article is illuminating and brings out quite fully and clearly the poetical spirit of Zen which is embodied in Faust. When I first read Faust, I was deeply impressed with the ideas pervading the work, thinking how strongly they reminded me of The spirit of Zen is really universal, as Dr. McCarthy states; it knows no distinction of East and West. In fact, Zen, being life itself, contains everything that goes into the make-up of life: Zen is poetry, Zen is philosophy, Zen is morality. Wherever there is life-activity, there is As long as we cannot imagine life to be limited in any way, Zen is present in every one of our experiences, but this ought not to be understood as a kind of obscure immanentism. There is nothing hidden in Zen: all is manifest, and only the dim-eyed ones are barred from seeing it. When I say that Zen is life, I mean that Zen is not to be confined within conceptualization, that Zen is what makes conceptualization possible, and therefore that Zen is not to be identified with any particular brand of ism. In this respect, Dr. Ames's comparison of Zen with pragmatism or existentialism may be said to be not quite to the point. It goes without saying that Zen has its own way of expressing itself, and also a theory to rationalize itself. But this ought not to be interpreted to mean that this theory is There is something in the theory of Zen that may pass into a form of pragmatism or existentialism, and I think Dr. Ames has taken up this point for discussion in his article on America, Existentialism, and Zen. Therefore, it is evident that his Zen does not cover the entirety of Zen as such. It is with this reservation, then, that I subscribe to most of what he states in his interesting and thought-provoking thesis.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Daisetz Teitaro Suzuki (1951) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: