Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Is something wrong with the argument at the beginning of Republic book II? M. B. Foster said yes, in an article in Mind 1937, pp. 386-393, 'A Mistake of Plato's in the Republic'. J. D. Mabbott defended Plato in the same periodical and the same year, pp. 468-474, 'Is Plato's Republic Utilitarian?' Mr. Foster replied the next year, pp. 226-232, 'A Rejoinder to Mr. Mabbott'. Neither party won an outright victory, but Mr. Mabbott's position is, I think, the stronger. I shall try to improve it, regaining ground that he wrongly conceded and covering a flank that he left exposed. 'I want to hear it praised itself by itself (Rep. 358 d I).' So Glaucon challenges Socrates to refute the Thrasymachean view of justice more effectively than he has done in Book I. Later Adeimantus says (367 d2):
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Christopher Kirwan (1965) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: