Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In New Zealand last century hanging was stopped, then re-introduced, before it was again ended. This provides a unique natural experimental test, using a reversal design, of the impact of the death penalty on homicide rates over 97 years. New Zealand is a developed country with similar correlates of homicide to other developed countries. This study tested the predictive power of 17 variables to develop a model of homicide rates. The difference between predicted and actual rates of homicide during the periods with and without the death penalty provided a test of the unique role of the death penalty in reducing homicide rates. The death penalty conditions were coincident with both reductions and increases in the homicide rate. This indicates that the death penalty had no consistent effect on homicide rates. The proportion of males, the levels of inflation and unemployment, together with their product – a misery index – did predict rates of homicide over this time.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Stewart Forsyth (2025) studied this question.