Key result
Zero-dimensional cardiovascular models require ~2x more heartbeats to achieve steady state with homeostatic control.
Why the study?
Closed-loop cardiovascular models rely heavily on steady-state simulations, but accuracy due to steady-state convergence is often assumed negligible.
In closed-loop cardiovascular models, achieving steady-state accuracy requires tailoring the number of simulated heartbeats to the presence of regulatory mechanisms to balance computational cost and accuracy.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Tailoring heartbeat count to regulatory mechanisms optimizes model efficiency; leaves open standardized protocols for zero-dimensional cardiovascular simulations.
Closed-loop cardiovascular models are becoming vital tools in clinical settings, making their accuracy and reliability paramount. While these models rely heavily on steady-state simulations, accuracy because of steady-state convergence is often assumed negligible. Using a reduced-order cardiovascular model created with the CircAdapt framework as a case study, we investigated steady-state convergence behaviour across various integration methods and simulation protocols. To minimize the effect of numerical errors, we first quantified the numerical errors originating from integration methods and model assumptions. We subsequently investigate this steady-state convergence error under two distinct conditions: first without, and then with homeostatic pressure-flow control (PFC), providing a comprehensive assessment of the CircAdapt framework's numerical stability and accuracy. Our results demonstrated that achieving a clinically accurate steady state required 7-15 heartbeats in simulations without regulatory mechanisms. When homeostatic control mechanisms were included to regulate mean arterial pressure and blood volume, more than twice the number of heartbeats was needed. By simulating a variable number of heartbeats tailored to each simulation's characteristics, an efficient balance between computational cost and steady-state accuracy can be achieved. Understanding this balance is crucial as cardiovascular models progress towards clinical use.This article is part of the theme issue 'Uncertainty quantification for healthcare and biological systems (Part 2)'.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Osta et al. (2025) studied Cardiovascular simulation (n=1,000). Homeostatic pressure-flow control (PFC) simulation vs. Simulation without regulatory mechanisms was evaluated on Number of heartbeats required to achieve a clinically accurate steady state. Achieving a clinically accurate steady state in the zero-dimensional cardiovascular model required 7-15 heartbeats without regulatory mechanisms, and more than twice as many with homeostatic control.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: