Key result
Health education with physical activity may aid short-term weight but is ineffective for BMI, lipids, and BP.
Why the study?
To examine the effects of integrated health education programmes with physical activity among community-dwelling older adults at risk of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease.
Do integrated health education programmes with physical activity improve cardiovascular risk factors in community-dwelling older adults at risk of ASCVD?
Systematic Review (n=1,973)
Do integrated health education programmes with physical activity improve cardiovascular risk factors in community-dwelling older adults at risk of ASCVD?
Integrated health education and physical activity programs show potential for short-term weight management in older adults at risk of ASCVD, but their effects on other cardiovascular risk factors remain inconclusive.
Does not support broad CV risk reduction via integrated programs in older adults; confirms limited benefit confined to short-term weight management.
Aims To examine the effects of integrated health education programmes with physical activity among community‐dwelling older adults at risk of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (ASCVD). Design Integrative review. Data Sources A systematic search of experimental studies was conducted in six electronic databases and one registry from inception to December 2022. Methods Two researchers independently conducted the eligibility screening, quality appraisal and data extraction. A total of 11 studies, which were published between 1996 and 2021, were included in the review and were analysed by narrative synthesis. Results The 11 included studies involved 1973 participants. The findings indicate that integrated health education programmes with physical activity have potential benefit in short‐term weight management among community‐dwelling older adults at risk of ASCVD. Nevertheless, the programmes appear ineffective on body mass index, short‐term lipid profiles, diastolic blood pressure (BP) and blood glucose. Further investigation is recommended to confirm the programme effects on physical activity level, exercise self‐efficacy, systolic BP, waist circumference, long‐term lipid profiles, long‐term weight management and cardiac endurance. The findings suggest that body mass index may not be a sensitive indicator of obesity in the elderly population and should be measured along with waist circumference to better predict the risk of ASCVD. The available evidence is restricted in its robustness and generalisability. As most included studies were conducted in the United States, more studies should be implemented in other countries to enhance study generalisability. Conclusions The effects of integrated health education programmes with physical activity among community‐dwelling older adults at risk of ASCVD remain inconclusive. Further research with adequate statistical power and good methodology is warranted. Impact The findings provide insights into whether health education programmes with physical activity effectively improve various outcomes, and suggest that researchers should include exercise self‐efficacy and cardiac endurance in future studies. Reporting Method Adhered to PRISMA reporting guidelines. No Patient or Public Contribution This review was conducted without patient or public participation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lo et al. (2024) conducted a systematic review in Atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease risk (n=1,973). Integrated health education programmes with physical activity was evaluated on Weight management, body mass index, lipid profiles, blood pressure, and blood glucose. Integrated health education programmes with physical activity in 1,973 older adults showed potential benefits for short-term weight management but were ineffective for BMI, lipid profiles, and BP.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: