Key result
Eight-second ExTRa Mapping recordings yield ~16% lower AF driver instability than 5-second recordings.
Why the study?
ExTRa Mapping was developed to visualize rotational activation as AF drivers, but the instability of these AF drivers required evaluation.
Observational (n=26)
Rotational activation assessed by ExTRa Mapping is unstable, requiring repetitive and longer recordings (e.g., 8 seconds) for reliable assessment.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Instability of rotational AF drivers on ExTRa Mapping warrants caution with short recordings; leaves open optimal duration for reliable assessment.
Background ExTRa Mapping™ has developed to visualize rotational activation as atrial fibrillation (AF) drivers. The current study was sought to evaluate the instability of AF drivers by ExTRa Mapping™. Methods Variation of nonpassively activated ratio (%NP) among three‐time repetitive recordings before and after pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) in left atrium was assessed in 26 persistent AF patients. The recoding time was set at 5 or 8 s for the respective patients. The outcome measures included %NP at each recording, mean value of the three‐time recordings, and the instability index, which was defined as maximum difference per mean %NP × 100 (%). Results Total 683 sites 2049 recordings were assessed. Mean %NP was 33.3(23.3–42.7)%, and higher in sites with severe (≥50%) and patchy low voltage area than those without, but not in those with severe complex fractionated atrial electrogram area. There was significant correlation between actual and mean %NP ( R = 0.86, P < .001), but maximum difference among the repetitive recordings was 16(10–24)%. The instability index of %NP was 55.9(30.9–83.6)%, and significantly lower at the recordings of 8 s compared with 5 s (50.6[28.6–78.4]% vs. 60.4[35.0–90.0]%, P = .004). Furthermore, it was higher at sites with lower reliability of the recordings. After PVI, mean %NP significantly decreased (28.7[18.3–36.7]% vs. 37.7[28.7–45.7]%, P < .001), but the instability index significantly increased compared with those before PVI (60.0[35.0–92.7]% vs. 48.9[29.1–75.0]%, P = .001). Conclusion Rotational activation as AF drivers assessed by ExTRa Mapping™ is unstable, and repetitive and longer recording is required for the reliable assessment even after PVI.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kawaji et al. (2022) conducted an observational in Persistent atrial fibrillation (n=26). ExTRa Mapping™ (8-second recordings) vs. ExTRa Mapping™ (5-second recordings) was evaluated on Instability index of nonpassively activated ratio (%NP) (p=0.004). Rotational activation as atrial fibrillation drivers assessed by ExTRa Mapping™ showed significant instability, which was lower with 8-second versus 5-second recordings.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: