Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Children are increasingly engaging in dialogue and interactions with AI agents that can mimic human behaviors, raising questions about how children perceive and communicate with AI compared to humans. In an experimental study with 119 children aged 4–8, participants co-created stories in three conditions: with a generative AI agent via a speaker, with a physically present human partner, or with a human partner who was hidden and audible only through a speaker. Results showed a clear distinction in children’s communication and perception of visible human partners compared to AI. Nuanced differences also emerged in children’s perceptions of hidden human partners versus AI. When physical appearance was absent, children relied on linguistic and paralinguistic cues to assess human-likeness, but physical appearance became a more dominant factor when available. These results shed light on implications for the design of child-facing AI technologies, offering insights into how speech and physical features can be optimized to meet children’s developmental and communicative needs. • We investigated children’s mind perception and communication with generative AI compared to humans, either physically present or audible only through a speaker. • Children perceived generative AI partners as having some degree of agency but lacking experience, which was a significant difference compared to their perception of a physically present human partner. • When comparing an AI partner with a human partner interacting through a speaker, children were less able to discern the differences between the two. • In the absence of human physical presence, children relied more heavily on the partner’s linguistic and paralinguistic cues to form their perceptions. However, when human physical presence was available, it became a more dominant factor. • As children grow, they increasingly associate embodiment with the perception of mind.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Xu et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: