Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The multicentric study by Fischman et al.1 established that the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI) in line-field confocal optical coherence tomography (LC-OCT) significantly improved the diagnosis of basal cell carcinoma (BCC) in European centres. While the authors reported promising findings, a closer reappraisal of their data reveals underexplored insights and potential methodological weaknesses that could refine their clinical and translational interpretation. The most striking observation is the uneven diagnostic gain across BCC subtypes. Accuracy for superficial BCCs increased from 0.812 to 0.964—the largest improvement among all categories—while benign imitators, such as sebaceous hyperplasia and nevi, showed minimal change.1 This suggests that the algorithm effectively identified the subtle optical morphology of superficial lesions, which are often missed by clinicians but carry high curative potential when detected early. Clinically, this improvement not only enhances early detection but also raises concerns about potential overdiagnosis, given that gains in specificity were limited. Similar sensitivity–specificity imbalances have been reported in systematic reviews of noninvasive imaging AI systems, underscoring the importance of threshold calibration to maintain diagnostic precision.2, 3 Another notable aspect concerns the differential benefit across experience levels. The sensitivity for novices increased from 0.63 to 0.93,1 whereas experts improved only modestly. This ‘expertise equalizer’ effect illustrates AI's capacity to accelerate learning and reduce inter-observer variability, expanding access to LC-OCT interpretation. However, convergence towards the model's internal bias may also reduce diagnostic diversity. Previous studies on human–AI collaboration in dermatologic imaging have shown that algorithmic guidance can foster overreliance, potentially diminishing clinicians' independent reasoning, even when overall accuracy remains high.4 The most consequential methodological issue lies in the dataset and sampling bias. The 685,000-frame training corpus and validation data originated primarily from European tertiary centres using identical LC-OCT systems, with Fitzpatrick phototypes unreported and limited representation of mucocutaneous or highly pigmented sites.1 Because LC-OCT optical contrast varies with melanin density and epidermal architecture, the lack of diverse skin tones restricts the external validity.5 Moreover, the inclusion of only diagnostically ‘equivocal’ lesions enriched the dataset for challenging cases, inflating the apparent advantage of AI. Twelve of the 43 evaluators also contributed to data collection,1 introducing potential recall bias despite washout procedures. These constraints align with broader discussions on fairness and inclusivity in the development of dermatological AI.6 Finally, a subtler but clinically relevant problem is interpretability bias. In approximately 6% of cases,1 diagnostic accuracy worsened with AI assistance because ambiguous heatmap overlays led users to change correct diagnoses. This paradox—where explainability tools inadvertently induce automation bias—highlights the need for calibrated visualization methods that enhance transparency while preserving clinical autonomy.7 Collectively, these findings reaffirm that AI-assisted LC-OCT increases sensitivity and diagnostic confidence, particularly for superficial BCCs and novice readers. However, the evidence reflects optimized rather than real-world conditions. Achieving equitable clinical integration will require prospective, multiethnic validation, calibrated performance in various phototypes and interpretability safeguards that preserve clinician independence and trust. None declared. None declared. Not applicable. Not applicable. Data sharing not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analysed during this study.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gao et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: