Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background: The Gail model and the model developed by Tyrer and Cuzick are two questionnaire-based approaches with demonstrated ability to predict development of breast cancer in a general population. Methods: We compared calibration, discrimination, and net reclassification of these models, using data from questionnaires sent every 2 years to 76,922 participants in the Nurses' Health Study between 1980 and 2006, with 4,384 incident invasive breast cancers identified by 2008 (median follow-up, 24 years; range, 1–28 years). In a random one third sample of women, we also compared the performance of these models with predictions from the Rosner–Colditz model estimated from the remaining participants. Results: Both the Gail and Tyrer–Cuzick models showed evidence of miscalibration (Hosmer–Lemeshow P < 0.001 for each) with notable (P < 0.01) overprediction in higher-risk women (2-year risk above about 1%) and underprediction in lower-risk women (risk below about 0.25%). The Tyrer–Cuzick model had slightly higher C-statistics both overall (P < 0.001) and in age-specific comparisons than the Gail model (overall C, 0.63 for Tyrer–Cuzick vs. 0.61 for the Gail model). Evaluation of net reclassification did not favor either model. In the one third sample, the Rosner–Colditz model had better calibration and discrimination than the other two models. All models had C-statistics <0.60 among women ages ≥70 years. Conclusions: Both the Gail and Tyrer–Cuzick models had some ability to discriminate breast cancer cases and noncases, but have limitations in their model fit. Impact: Refinements may be needed to questionnaire-based approaches to predict breast cancer in older and higher-risk women.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Glynn et al. (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: