Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Annotations in books and musical scores may seem incidental to the text they accompany. Sections highlighted for study or pleasure, comments in the margins, ownership inscriptions, performance indications penciled into sheet music, added indexes or shelf marks to find things again, and more, are often referred to as “marginalia” or “paratexts,” stressing the supplementary quality of these traces. Thus envisaged, they are sometimes the object of specialist interests rather than a central concern of textual scholarship. This article reflects on the disciplinary priorities that shaped such hierarchical views of marks in literary and musical texts, views that in turn “disciplined” scholars to write histories reproducing similarly hierarchical orders of things and people. I use examples of present-day scholarly treatments of annotations as a prompt for a broad reconsideration of textual scholarship’s world making while handling traces of all kinds, including those of authors. Choosing to visualize traces within temporary aggregations of things and people becomes here the premise for a more textured and unstable historical recounting of the “social lives” of texts. Much can be gained from foregrounding the contingency of these aggregations. I see it as an opportunity for scholars to be no less rigorous while at the same time renouncing to assert themselves as the authority naming and explaining everything textual objects did or do. In this, the article’s methodological stance answers the call for reparative modes and tones of scholarship, chipping away at the monumental views that past textual exegeses have built of certain music, certain literature, and certain academic writing.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fabio Morábito (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: