Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Community Engagement – What it is and Why is it Important Community is a social construct, an idea, and not a tangible product that can be seen, touched, or experienced. It is a set of interactions with a cultural system governed by human behaviors where there are certain expectations from other community members. The idea of “togetherness” makes the community a crucial resource for policy development and program implementation related to health, social development, and social welfare, as well as multidimensional concepts such as One Health (OH). Aristotelian philosophy considers community to be composed of different individuals working together and tied by common goals and purposes,[1] while the Durkheimian tradition defines small communities as a group of people who may eat, work, or spend leisure time together.[2] The WHO defines community engagement (CE) in health as “a process of developing relationships that enable stakeholders to work together to address health-related issues and promote well-being to achieve positive health impact and outcomes.”[3] The foundational principles of CE are the sustainable relationship between the community and wider stakeholders, including policymakers, service providers, and research teams that are based on trust and intention of working together to achieve certain outcomes. CE has emerged as an important tool for policymakers and researchers not only to learn about needs and challenges at the community level but also to make policy-making and implementation more participatory while establishing a balance between top-down and bottom-up approaches. Magnitude of Antimicrobial Resistance and Strategies (Global Action Plan) “Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is the process by which microbes (including bacteria, viruses, fungi, and parasites) change or evolve to survive the drugs used to destroy them.”[4] In 2019, bacterial-associated AMR caused 4·95 million (3.62–6.57) deaths including 1.27 million (95% unit interval (UI) 0.911–1.71) deaths directly attributable to bacterial AMR.[5] AMR is also projected to have a detrimental impact on economic growth, resulting in a 2%–3.5% decline in GDP along with a 3%–8% fall in livestock, costing USD 100 trillion to the world by 2050.[6] AMR not only impacts health but increases the burden on health systems, affects food production systems, causes a financial burden on the population, and causes spillage of resistant bacteria across species. There are multisectoral drivers of AMR that include lack of stewardship in the use of antibiotics in human, animal, and agriculture sectors, lack of infection control and preparedness, poor water and sanitation, and inappropriate hazardous waste disposal. The WHO’s Global Action Plan (GAP) on AMR was endorsed at the 68th World Health Assembly in May 2015,[7] thus flagging AMR as a global threat and a pandemic in evolution. GAP focused on (1) improving awareness and understanding of AMR through effective communication, education, and training; (2) strengthening knowledge and evidence base through surveillance and research; (3) reducing the incidence of infection through effective sanitation, hygiene, and infection prevention measures; (4) optimizing the use of antimicrobial medicines in human and animal health; and, (5) developing the economic case for sustainable investment in new medicines, diagnostic tools, vaccines, and related interventions.[7] It also committed to supporting member countries to develop National Action Plans (NAPs).[7] Other multilateral bodies also endorsed the adoption of One Health approach to bring all stakeholders together to combat AMR.[8] Not all member states have developed their NAPs though and implementation continues to be challenging among those with NAPs. Significantly, CE remains un-or under-addressed as a critical resource in all action plans. Need for Community Engagement in Antimicrobial Resistance CE enables that knowledge is equitably co-produced and translates to behavior change without a top-down prescription or any enforcement of behavior change.[9] Health behavioral interventions that do not centre-stage communities suffer from wastage of resources, lack of trust, and ownership among the community and, therefore, generally miss the program objectives. CE ensures feedback to programs and can enhance timely solutions and incremental attainment of the intended outcomes. A study on AMR at the community level in India found the burden of AMR high in both rural and urban sites and that data obtained from tertiary care could not capture the realities at the local level.[10] It underscored the need for AMR stewardship at the local level and co-developing contextual local policies for AMR in resource-limited settings. Challenges in Community Engagement in Antimicrobial Resistance Mere knowledge about community practices and behaviors will not be enough to bring about changes in practice among prescribers and dispensers.[11] The OH framework is not limited to understanding only human behaviors but also wildlife, environment, agriculture, marine life, and veterinary practices. AMR, unlike most health programs that are implemented top-down, is a complex problem involving multi-level interactions of a range of actors and shaped by norms, behaviors, and practices rooted in diverse sociocultural contexts. Concerns are that these action plans view and frame communities merely as beneficiaries and not as critical partners in policy development and implementation. Most clauses and subclauses are limited to assessing knowledge, attitude, and practice (KAP). The limitations of KAP studies are well known: the relationship between health-related behavior and the characteristics measured by KAP surveys are complex and difficult to quantify, suffer from analyst biases, is dependent upon whether respondents reveal what they really practice, and respondents may not think of diseases or risk factors as researchers do.[12] KAP studies tend to be limited to selected communities, such as fisheries, with the aim of capacity-building. Only a handful of targeted studies have been conducted to understand norms, beliefs, knowledge, practices, and challenges among community and community health providers and to understand the reasons for the misuse of antibiotics within communities and para-veterinarians. The lack of such information hinders effective CE, with communities often ending up as subordinate entities rather than stakeholders who are engaged within the citizen-science framework of co-designing solutions, the most ethical approach to CE.[13] Communities in our region have distinctive features implying the range for tailored CE solutions. The starting point is to be able to identify what CE approach will be appropriate for a specific setting – such as involving individuals, groups, community representatives, or the whole community. It is also necessary to adopt transparent measures to represent various classes, castes, ethnicities, genders, and education levels in the CE process. Decentralization decision-making is the key to CE. Balancing power between communities and external stakeholders (researchers and decision-makers), who often wield greater influence due to their resources, is vital. If left unchecked, the more powerful stakeholders may overshadow the voices and needs of the community and dominate the process. Finally, there should be a focus on cross-learning from successful public health policies and health interventions such as nutrition programs, polio eradication, and tuberculosis within the country and across regions, which may be able to shape CE for AMR. The focus of action plans has mostly been on the capacity building of health-care providers, but there is a significant unmet need for the capacity building of policymakers so that adequate and effective decision-making can be ensured. SEAR Specific Issues All countries in the the WHO’s South East Asia Region (SEAR) face significant burdens in terms of AMR-related mortality, morbidity, and economic loss.[14] Following the GAP in 2015, all SEAR member states developed their NAPs, and by 2022, eight countries had updated their NAPs after completing the first 5 years.[14] Implementation has been a challenge though. The Third OH Situational Analysis 2021, while highlighting key areas of success, presented the implementation gaps in the NAPs, including a lack of education and awareness generation in the environment sector and implementation of an AMR early warning system.[15] Major hurdles for adapting GAPs according to local needs were the lack of an adequate budget for developing an operation plan for NAPs and knowledge gaps due to weak surveillance systems and research at the ground level. India Case Study Following the GAP on AMR in 2015, India came up with its NAP for AMR in 2017 under the aegis of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.[16] Conceptualized as a 5-year plan, the NAP borrowed five key strategic priorities from GAP and further added the sixth pillar on “leadership.” All six pillars address issues across sectors and stakeholders. These objectives were to be achieved through effective communication, education and training, surveillance, effective infection, prevention, and control. The first strategic priority of the NAP focuses on raising awareness among policymakers, the public and farmers, and training and education of professionals. The second priority focuses on animals, humans, food, and the environment to strengthen laboratories and surveillance. The third priority focuses on health, community, and community environment. Regulation and antimicrobial stewardship are the focus areas of the fourth priority. The fifth and sixth priorities focus on medicine, diagnostics, innovations, financing, and collaboration. Following the framing of the NAP, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Delhi, and Andhra Pradesh came up with the State Action Plan for Containment of Antimicrobial Resistance. All states adopted six priority areas from NAP. Taking a step forward, Kerala and Andhra Pradesh have added additional specific details to each of the priority areas.[17,18] However, CE in all these plans, including the NAP, is not well defined. Even though the second strategic priority of NAP subclause “2.1.1. Strengthen capacity for laboratory-based surveillance of AMR in humans, animals, food, and environment” does mention the word “community,”[16] it is only used to refer to the importance of community data. Similarly, the third strategic priority on reduction in infection through effective prevention and control of NAP subclause “3.1.1.4. Streamline hand hygiene and sanitation as components of performance monitoring/performance payment within different schemes or quality programs like Swachh Bharat Abhiyaan, Kayakalp and Swachh Swasth Sarvatra initiatives” also mentions “community and environment” as an important component only for developing infection prevention and control (IPC) strategy. Strategic priority three also promotes increasing awareness among the community for hygiene/sanitation practices. In strategic priority, “3.3 on Strengthen infection prevention outside healthcare settings to limit the development and spread of AMR” emphasizes on involving community leaders in media campaigns, information, education, and communication at the village level, and schools, showcasing importance in the community. It also talks about assessing KAP within the community to strengthen IPC.[12] Further to this strategic priority, area four also mentions the community for appropriate use of antibiotics. Subclause “4.4.1.2. develop awareness campaigns targeted at consumers and community, including schools and colleges, regarding patient risks of inappropriate antibiotic use” again emphasizes awareness for the community. Strategic priority area four also focuses on monitoring antibiotic use in the community.[16] Following the NAP, near-identical objectives and sub-objectives were incorporated in the SAPs of Andhra Pradesh, Delhi, Kerala, and Madhya Pradesh. Significantly, Kerala’s action plan, objective 1.17 mentions “Study/Research on changes in KAP among farmers, veterinarians, and fisheries professionals, following implementation of training program.”[17] Way Forward To make a CE initiative successful, it is important to involve the community before planning, during implementation, and after implementation, which is a necessary but cost-intensive exercise. Considering the lack of dedicated funding for AMR, an effective CE may seem a far-flung dream. Framed as a biological problem, AMR interventions have been top-down and technical. It is no exaggeration that AMR needs to be recast as a biosocial problem that cannot be addressed without a strategically planned CE. To understand social norms and behaviors, social scientists need to be a part of the core team and not come in only to design social mobilization activities. The WHO has moved forward with a “people-centered approach”[19] and designed a core package of interventions to support NAPs. Key elements include engaging with civil society and community-based organizations and underlines the importance of community leadership, participatory decision-making, mutual understanding and communication, and mobilizing resources for CE.[18] However, the revision and operationalization of action plans based on this package is yet to make substantial progress. There is a need to reorient the policy approach in the region to consider AMR more as a social and behavioral issue. Backed by a costed budgetary allocation, the investment needs to be in empowering communities – not only to design an awareness and education plan but also to involve them in decision-making and enable appropriate choices in production and consumption. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dasgupta et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: