Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
One foundational element of Rob Kling's research and writing is his critical perspective on the nature, role, and dynamics of computerization. His main argument was that one should view as dubious any statements that are not grounded in empirical evidence or theoretical analysis. Rob's work was replete with critical refutation, in which he challenged assumptions or statements about computerization and provided alternative interpretations. Much of his work delivered indictments against hyperbolic statements that claimed either utopian or dystopian outcomes from computerization. However, some of his own writings on emerging technologies tended to be dismissive and marginalizing, revealing in his own work some of the weaknesses he pointed out in others' rhetoric and writing. This article identifies intellectual traps inherent in critical perspectives that can catch even the most acute practitioners. The objective is to help elucidate and stabilize the epistemological foundations for Rob's critical perspective on the role of computerization. Keywords: critical perspectivesocial informatics Notes 1 In deference to our close associations with Rob Kling over the years, we refer to him simply as Rob throughout this article. We do not extend this familiarity to others. Authorship order is proportional to years with Rob. 2 The opening and closing quotes are from the poem, “Job's Tears,” by Scottish bard Robin Williamson, set to music by the Incredible String Band in 1968. 3 SIGART is the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) Special Interest Group on Artificial Intelligence. The AFIPS Fall Joint Computer Conference was the most important conference in the computing field at that time, run by an umbrella organization that included ACM and similar societies. 4 Mary Shelley conceived her masterpiece Frankenstein in 1816, providing one of the earliest explorations of moral hazard from the power of science, an iconic symbol that survives to this day. Jules Verne's Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea, written in 1870, explored the moral dangers of technology embodied in war-making power. H.G. Wells's The Time Machine, written in 1895, foresaw a future in which not even advanced technology could prevent the demise of human life. E. M. Forster's The Machine Stops, written in 1909, considered a future of humans dependent on a great provisioning machine that suddenly stops, with catastrophic consequences. Evgeny Zamyatin's We (1920), arguably the first dystopian novel, explored the power of technology for social control and influenced Orwell. Huxley's Brave New World followed in 1932. 5 This account is based on personal communication between Rob and John King. 6 Feldman coedited an early landmark AI book with Rob's former PhD adviser (Feigenbaum & Feldman, 1963). 7 We are aware of what Rob read because he told us about all books he read, and made us read them, too, if we hadn't done so already. 8 This idea is particularly clear in Kling and Scacchi (1980, 1982). 9 For background on this project and Rob's role in it, see King (2004) King, J. L. 2004. Rob Kling and the Irvine School. The Information Society, 20(2): 97–99. [Taylor & Francis Online], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar]. 10 Based on personal communication with John King. 11 Based on personal communication with John King, who saw some of these papers. 12 Rob once remarked to John King that his “personal computer” in 1968 was a 36-bit KA-10 processor with a maxed-out main memory of 256 Kbytes. He often did his work in the middle of the night, and was the only user on the machine. 13 “Moore's Law” stated that the number of transistors that could be put on an integrated circuit chip doubles every 18 months, and became a paraphrase for a range of technology advances that follow a nonlinear or exponential growth path (with exponent greater than 1). 14 For a nice discussion of exponential growth, see Eriksen (2001) Eriksen, T. H. 2001. Tyranny of the moment, London: Pluto Press. [Google Scholar]. 15 http://www.glreach.com/globstats/ 16 Because of the hasty demise of AFIPS, at the time of writing, no one seems to know who owns the copyright to hundreds of seminal papers by Rob and others, which for this reason have not been reproduced and are unavailable outside of the few libraries that collected them. 17 The ad can be found on several web sites using search terms such as Apple Macintosh 1984 Super Bowl. Apple followed it with an infamous 1985 Super Bowl ad showing lemming-like office workers following one another off a cliff. 18 Thirty years ago Xerox PARC made an investment that gave it a computing infrastructure a decade ahead of virtually everyone else. Today, anyone can purchase an up-to-date moderately-priced system and get capability that rivals that of a typical researcher with a 3-year-old system. 19 From personal communication with John King.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
King et al. (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: