Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
ABSTRACTHow does the institutional context shape how much party position change on LGBTQ+ rights is attributable to conversion (i.e., incumbents changing their positions) versus replacement (i.e., legislative turnover)? Research on party position change on LGBTQ+ rights has focused on the US, meaning findings may be limited to a particular institutional context. Turning to the Canadian case, I find that party position change on LGBTQ+ rights was larger in magnitude and happened faster in Canada than in the US. I argue that institutional differences created opportunities for more considerable and rapid conversion and replacement in Canada compared to the US. Institutional opportunities for conversion and replacement can vary by country, by party, and over time. As work on conversion, replacement, and party position change expands further beyond the US, it will be important to consider how the institutional context shapes opportunities for – and the dynamics of – party position change.KEYWORDS: Political partiesLGBTQ+ politicsconversionreplacementsame-sex marriagetransgender rightsgender identity AcknowledgementsI would like to thank Quinn Albaugh, Emily Grafton, and the journal's anonymous reviewers for their constructive suggestions.Disclosure statementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Notes1 Parliament can use the notwithstanding clause to override certain sections of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms for five years at a time.2 In Canada, the federal government can refer questions to the Supreme Court of Canada for an advisory opinion. This is usually done if the government has questions about the constitutionality of legislation.3 Pairing refers to cases in which a government MP and an MP from one of the opposition parties agree to abstain from voting. This can be done for a variety of reasons, including when MPs cannot be present or to allow an MP to avoid voting their party's position.4 This is because only recorded votes on government bills and private member's bills – not motions – are available through LEGISinfo.5 This is calculated between each pair of votes but information about the very few longtime Stayers (i.e., those around for all votes or all votes on each issue) are available in the Supplementary Materials.6 In one case, a socially conservative Liberal was defeated by a socially progressive NDP member (York South–Weston). The remaining Liberal Dropouts were those who simply did not vote in 2013.7 Newcomers in this situation included, for example, Mel Arnold, Luc Berthold, Jim Eglinski, Marilyn Gladu, Larry Maguire, John Nater, Jamie Schmale, and Karen Vecchio.8 Newcomers in this situation included Sylvie Boucher, Gérard Deltell, Joël Godin, Bernard Généreux, and Alain Rayes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elizabeth Baisley (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: