Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The onset of the 2008 financial crisis occasioned a widespread resurgence in materialist methods in the US academy. In the disciplines of economics and political theory, a renewed interest in Marx coincided with greater attention to the long durée of capitalist wealth accumulation (think Thomas Piketty’s bestselling 2012 study Capital in the Twenty-First Century), and increased visibility for pre-crisis works that tracked the historical relationship between Marxism and race (for instance, Cedric Robinson’s Black Marxism: The Making of the Black Radical Tradition, originally published in 1983) and Marxism and gender (for instance, Silvia Federici’s Caliban and the Witch, originally published in 2004). Meanwhile, heterodox economic theories, such as those presented in David Graeber’s Debt: The First 5000 years (2011), found a growing audience in the mainstream, and numerous scholars produced comprehensive critiques of the neoclassical theories that had held sway for decades in economics departments in the United States (see, for example, Radika Desai’s 2013 Geopolitical Economy: After US Hegemony, Globalization and Empire). The writings of Fredric Jameson, long seen as the most important living Marxist critic, moved to the center of literary and cultural studies, displacing the poststructuralist theories that had pervaded humanities discourse at the turn of the twenty-first century. In literary studies, Colleen Lye, Nicholas Brown, Sianne Ngai, Anna Kornbluh, and Joe Cleary were among the many US-based scholars who developed sophisticated Marxist frameworks for what was increasingly referred to as a “global” or “world” literary system.In the study of post-1945 US literary fiction, as I have recently argued elsewhere (Lawrence 2024), scholars of the past two decades have mostly gravitated toward one of two methodological approaches: institutionalism and neo-Jamesonianism.1 Although few of the institutionalist scholars have adopted an overtly Marxist or neo-Marxist approach, they have nearly all taken the material conditions of contemporary literary production as a primary concern. This is particularly true of those institutionalist scholars who have studied the publishing industry, whether in the guise of the “Big 5” corporate-backed conglomerates (Dan Sinykin, Richard So, Laura McGrath) or digital platforms like Amazon and Instagram that have emerged to rival them (Mark McGurl, Sarah Brouillette). These scholars have provided us with valuable accounts of the internal mechanisms of the contemporary book industry, persuasively arguing that the corporate takeover of publishing firms over the past forty years has irrevocably changed the production and selection of literary writing. As Brouillette (2022: 121) aptly sums up the situation, the relentless acquisition of independent imprints by transnational media companies beginning in the 1970s has led to a vastly unequal system in which “prized high-earning writers become general social commentators or even global celebrities, while the rest are left struggling to make ends meet.” Scholars in what Brouillette dubs the “new US publishing studies” have compellingly demonstrated just how much the material factors of literary production—agenting, acquiring, editing, printing, marketing, distributing, and so on—shape the books that finally arrive (or don’t arrive) in the reader’s hands.However, the institutionalist scholars in the new US publishing studies have proved less adept at illuminating the narrative worlds those books contain. Brouillette, So, and McGrath almost entirely eschew close readings, preferring to concentrate on the market dynamics that dictate who gets published and why. Sinykin and McGurl almost exclusively read contemporary novels as self-reflexive allegories of their conditions of production: a literary work published by the Big 5 inevitably speaks to what it means to be a literary work published by the Big 5; a literary work published on Amazon speaks to what it means to be published in the age of Amazon. In some instances, this mode of reading has clear explanatory power. Sinykin (2023: 19), building on an important essay by Lee Konstantinou, makes a compelling case that much of contemporary Anglophone autofiction is “preoccupied with the book industry” and often “projects the fantasy of victory over the systems that threaten to interfere in the cultivation of the expressive self.” McGurl (2021: xii) convincingly argues that Amazon’s efforts to “reforge contemporary literary life as an adjunct to online retail” can be linked to its emergence as a primary engine for popular genre fiction. I’m persuaded that the novels of Jeff Bezos’s ex-wife McKenzie Scott can lend insight into its founder’s early vision for Amazon’s imagined community. Yet it seems like a much greater stretch to say that all novels published by Amazon or the Big Five are about publishing, or even that those fictional works that depict the industry can be reduced to that depiction. Reading for institutional allegories of publishing can teach us a lot about the industry, but it has less to say about contemporary literature itself as an imaginative enterprise.The second prominent materialist approach to post‒1945 US fiction, which takes its principle methodological cues from Jameson’s theorization of postmodernism as the “cultural logic of late capitalism,” has sought to locate the contradictions of a postindustrial capitalist system centered on US finance in the internal contradictions of cultural texts. The most influential scholars working in this vein are arguably Annie McClanahan and Leigh Claire La Berge, though Rachel Greenwald Smith, Mitchum Huehls, and Alison Shonkweiler also deploy many of its signature moves in their scholarship. Whether authors in this vein refer to the contemporary period as one of finance capitalism (McClanahan, La Berge, and Shonkweiler) or of neoliberalism (Greenwald Smith and Huehls), they share the belief that a key feature of post‒1945 narrative texts is their ability to lay bare the mechanisms of the capitalist system itself. McClanahan (2017: 2) makes this claim explicitly in Dead Pledges: “Debt is such a ubiquitous yet elusive social form that we can most clearly and carefully understand it by looking at how our culture has sought to represent it,” while La Berge (2014: 9) advances a more modest version of it in her assertion that the financial fiction of the long 1980s “offers access to a history of financialization.” Like nearly all of the other scholars in the neo-Jamesonian line, McClanahan and La Berge attribute to writers and other cultural actors a kind of economic sixth sense, such that the texts they produce reveal the “real” structures of economic production and consumption.Despite their often lucid descriptions of the cultural dilemmas presented by neoliberal/finance capitalism, these neo-Jamesonian scholars never adequately address the question of why narrative texts (rather than, say, empirical research) possess such privileged insight into these complex economic processes. Although they frequently apply the language of the social sciences, as in La Berge and Shonkwiler’s (2014: 15) assertion in Reading Capitalist Realism that the “capitalist realist” narrative mode “model[s] the very transformative capitalist processes of commodification and financialization it records,” they struggle to demonstrate how plot- and character-based literary works reach the conclusions that one would expect from numerical or experimental analysis (how exactly can a novel “model” financialization?). Their cultural analysis largely proceeds by yoking abbreviated close readings of literary fiction that thematizes finance or debt to speculative affirmations of the empirical validity of that fictional treatment. In her account of Tom Wolfe’s Bonfire of the Vanities as a capitalist realist novel, for instance, La Berge buttresses her analysis of the novel’s economic, racial, and gendered imaginaries by countenancing the idea that Wolfe’s 1987 novel accurately prefigured the stock market crash that occurred three days after its publication. Speaking of the simultaneity of the appearance of Bonfire of the Vanities (1987), the release of Oliver Stone’s film Wall Street (1987), and the market crash, La Berge (2014: 77) asserts,The roundabout phrasing of these sentences should not distract us from their function within La Berge’s argument: she at once acknowledges that the link she establishes between the market crash and financial narratives of the period is purely speculative (“the narratives had just arrived”), and implies that such speculation is justified because of the Jamesonian dictum that narrative form presents an imaginary resolution to a real contradiction. Even as La Berge rhetorically distances herself from the vulgar Marxist position that cultural texts merely “reflect” economic processes, both the language she uses to describe “capitalist realism” (“records,” “models,” “captures”) and her reading method itself suggest that she does finally rely on such a one-to-one correspondence method. In any case, if novelists really had the predictive powers La Berge ascribes to them, there would likely be a much bigger market for them on Wall Street itself.I am not the first to express reservations about this approach. In his 2009 essay “Reading on the Left,” Christopher Nealon (2023: 83) observes in a passage partially addressed to Jameson’s The Political Unconscious (1981),In my opinion, Nealon’s evaluation holds even more true for materialist criticism of post–1945 US fiction now than fifteen years ago.2 Both institutionalist and neo-Jamesonian scholars have afforded us sophisticated accounts of the literary marketplace and the marketplace more generally, but they have done so at the expense of a holistic account of how literary history and form fit within this picture. Even those materialist scholars who underscore the centrality of form often do so, if I may be permitted the pun, in a pro forma way. They are almost always in a hurry to move beyond the complexities of narrative structure to something else: institutions, networks, capitalism itself.I undertake this long windup to my review of Adam Kelly’s New Sincerity: American Fiction in the Neoliberal Age for two reasons: first, because I believe that Kelly’s monograph is the best book yet written about US fiction in the era of neoliberalism/financial capitalism, and second, because I believe that its true innovation at the level of method becomes clear only when we set it against the dominant trends in post–1945 US literary studies of the past decade and a half. To my mind, New Sincerity is the first scholarly monograph on contemporary US fiction since McGurl’s The Program Era: Postwar Fiction and the Rise of Creative Writing (2009) that fully meets Nealon’s demand for a literary materialism that “really absorb[s] the particulars of literary history.” The key passage announcing Kelly’s departure from the critical consensus comes midway through his introduction. Referring to the question of how fiction writers established themselves in an era “determined by the economic character of language” and the “conglomerate character of literary publishing,” Kelly maintains that these “moral and epistemological questions . . . are primarily addressed by the writers featured in New Sincerity as questions of literary form” (21). Kelly goes on to say that his book will “mainly refer to literary New Sincerity as an aesthetic” and that “aspects of this aesthetic can be grasped through related notions such as sensibility and structure of feeling.” Although Kelly does not openly critique either the neo-Jamesonian line or that of the new publishing studies, this statement makes clear his intent to delineate an approach to contemporary US fiction that balances attention to the way economics has impinged on literary production with attention to how literature itself responds to economics in the aesthetic realm.The central argument of New Sincerity is that the dominant strain of fiction produced by “post-boomer” US writers between 1989 and 2008 responded to two major challenges, one literary-historical and one politico-economic. In the realm of literary history, this generation of writers grappled with the perceived exhaustion of the postmodern “irony” that pervaded the literary field from the late 1960s to the 1980s, particularly in the work of “high” postmodernists such as William Gaddis, Thomas Pynchon, and John Barth. In the realm of the politico-economic, these writers produced their work under the shadow of an ever-expanding neoliberal governance model “that validate[d] self-interest above all other ends” (20) and that gradually appropriated the very postmodern strategies that had earlier been used as a form of ideological critique. These claims are not new to Kelly’s book. In his earliest essays on the literary New Sincerity, beginning with his now and the New Sincerity in American Kelly on relationship to literary postmodernism and how the of in Kelly by and his a toward the of and a of complex in narrative and In his Kelly his analysis of the New Sincerity in fiction to address its economic, and institutional on the as the best for the from the of the to the financial crisis of 2008 in which this generation published its most fiction. The of Kelly’s book less in the of its and have been on the New Sincerity for over a and with neoliberalism has been a scholarly for even in its to and the most of the criticism his The book on the of the institutionalist and neo-Jamesonian Greenwald Smith, Sinykin, and McGurl, and it also works through for reading the US literature of this period that have since the of Kelly’s particularly Lee influential of and critique of the of the literary generation in and American in the Kelly’s in New Sincerity is his compelling that the major literary authors of the neoliberal period its economic, and social into of literary readings of and the book makes the claim that the growing in post‒1945 studies to on material factors of literary texts has scholars to the internal to the texts on a both and Kelly that we understand the literature of the New Sincerity in from a neoliberal cultural in which Kelly Smith on logic of the market into of the New Sincerity at once to that neoliberal logic at the level of fictional and to it through to the of its are in Kelly early the of can I do not the at the of the at the of In of these instances, the New Sincerity of this not to the of of postmodern but to a to the of through to this of becomes the signature of New Sincerity fiction both the of beyond and the of that within a increasingly by the of the Kelly the for this in his first on the of as its belief from his early character that in the culture of late are like in Kelly the to address this in his essays and fiction. In Kelly’s the for was that the very means developed for the language of the market was always at of the economic logic it to The literary that on was to in his works a such that the was an aesthetic and that the and its as Kelly the logic of neoliberalism is on an and the only way to such self-interest is to the and the other In a will the rest of the Kelly that vision of the New Sincerity as much from the as from the since is in and is only in the In his on and Kelly that this of how to under neoliberal capitalism is the of this and that these to address that in the very form of their be not has Kelly’s conclusions In New and (2017: a critique of Kelly’s about the New Sincerity, other his of the from the that such is only to the in the is a validity to and about the and gender in fiction, which often not on and his literary which often not in of As Kelly (2017: in his to the scholars such as McGurl, and had taken up of race and gender in fiction at the of and writing. Yet it is by means clear to that in about such the literary New Sincerity as a To my mind, Kelly’s most in the are the I would that the most compelling to to of our of his is that it is to the of contemporary Anglophone fiction of and postmodern was and adopted in the US literary and while his may have been mostly and many of his best were not should that Smith arguably the most Black Anglophone of that was her living is a in the that case for reading at the of a study centered on the literary and cultural of most is to Kelly’s that such in New Sincerity, to how a of US writers the and gendered of the New Sincerity though New first two on and set the for the readings that it I at his analysis of that the true of the New Sincerity fully into for In the Sincerity Kelly early novels the strain in American the work of and that a central of The the and (2009) is to a aesthetic position of American from cultural to centrality over the neoliberal the as with the were more and Kelly on the criticism on early influential by and Thomas Yet Kelly’s primary in the is to underscore just how the of those novels has been in both and such that while of and with in Kelly in the of The New it for these as a that new of race than the way of In to texts and Kelly that the novels themselves often the in American that them, the very questions about and the commodification of that often about In what we have now to as Kelly’s will suggest that one as a or critique of neoliberal and seems to . . . to the question of . . . how to read its Whether or not one the validity of this move will likely on how one Kelly’s argument that the New of and the narrative and structures of fiction. I both by his of texts and by his methodological on how often contemporary US literary criticism to for texts that Kelly’s of their does not that New Sincerity all of the literary historical questions to the period from the of the to the of the 2008 financial After mostly on authors and the to three books of the on political American the and In their of the of transnational of the 1960s and these novels a of that less in the the of Kelly’s study up to this has in to Jameson, that the New Sincerity writers are of to read the political of their the novels of and in to strain against the of this in I’m that the fiction of and does a to always itself the question or of how writers themselves are with neoliberalism and its of I read American as in the less the of political through than the in which such political would be most I don’t believe this at the of Kelly’s is that to his claim that the literary New Sincerity is the aesthetic” of the period from 1989 to 2008 while at the that on the New Sincerity as the aesthetic of the period would the contemporary literary also as I tracked Kelly’s analysis of a novel that I as mostly on the of the of how to I some for assertion that the literary New Sincerity means by which writers the neoliberal version than an this new in Kelly all the authors that Kelly studies themselves up to this of The Kelly my as a is not because I of all the by these it is because his to their in the most compelling of this US literary generation published to in past the first decade of the to the literature that emerged after the neoliberal was into question by the 2008 financial crisis and the that the cultural produced by Wall Street in which in the of and the of and other Kelly that the literary of that the neoliberal period into something to a of reading of this is nearly to in any of his to New Sincerity, I a very argument about and in an and that at almost the as Kelly’s book. Like I believe that the social of the the first of Black the of and to a for the cultural and political left in the United arguably for the first since the of the long I also fully with Kelly to the period addressed in this the contemporary social is one in which the of have become and in which the with the system seems less of a now that the system is and while to lay to the Yet victory in the largely by his increased share of and has any that we in what Kelly in the as the I’m this review with the of a that Kelly possess when New Sincerity, as we have all this past the is to is that the two decades that will have between the 2008 crisis and departure from in may their internal one that with the of the literary and political left to US culture the I would that the of the literary of that Kelly accurately in the years into a more literature of the visibility of literary texts has largely been by how those texts their to the now the of the United In my Kelly’s book has become more than less because of these New Sincerity finally us is in the of the perceived exhaustion of a postmodern cultural and the of a neoliberal a of authors found the aesthetic to the most questions of their is a both for contemporary US writers and for the who study
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jeffrey Lawrence (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: