Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
N We welcome thoughtful discussion of the multidimensional (MD) research approach, including proposals to make the methodology even more effective than it is. However, Ghadessy's critique of MD analysis is flawed in four ways. First, it does not acknowledge the strengths of MD analysis or address whether alternative approaches can retain those strengths; second, it does not reflect an understanding of the linguistic and statistical bases of MD analysis; third, it incorrectly assumes that MD analysis has claimed to be an all-inclusive approach to linguistic variation; and, finally, much of the critique is based on personal preference for linguistic analysis rather than external considerations such as the uses for the analysis. The main point of Ghadessy's critique seems to be the desirability of including linguistic characteristics-especially discourse features-in future MD analyses. We fully agree with this general goal, and we have called for similar extensions in nearly every published MD study. For example, in the article under review, we note that additional features-including rhetorical and lexical features-also deserve attention (p. 43). However, we do not believe that the desirability of future extensions constitutes a major deficiency in MD methodology or diminishes the important contributions of past MD research. Although Ghadessy raises several specific criticisms in his review, he does not address or acknowledge the strengths of MD analysis:
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Biber et al. (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: