Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
any of the most worthwhile theoretical and methodological challenges social scientists face spring from phenomena that link different levels of aggregation. For some concepts, the system-level manifestation is the summation of properties of individuals aggregate demand for a product or district partisanship, for instance. For these, the challenge is in properly formulating the aggregation rule that produces the social choice. The difficulty of this task should not be underestimated, but its practitioners do begin from a single, consensual perspective methodological individualism and this facilitates coherent theorizing by grounding key concepts in a common foundational assumption. Other multi-level constructs lack this characteristic feature. Legitimacy is a paradigmatic example, a systemlevel property that has no direct individual-level counterpart. Research on legitimacy is particularly difficult because the key decision, choosing the right theoretical perspective, presents a dilemma for which there is no necessarily correct solution. Proponents of a macro viewpoint note that evaluating a political system's claim to legitimacy depends on the presence of constitutional guarantees of access and equality, properties that can be competently judged by an outside observer. Moreover, they warn that popular support is neither a necessary nor sufficient condition for legitimacy, since history shows examples of regimes widely judged legitimate that were overthrown and others that retained their incumbency through manipulation or force in spite of being clearly illegitimate. But proponents of the individuallevel perspective also have a strong claim to define how legitimacy should be conceptualized and research on it organized. Even the most
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
M. Stephen Weatherford (1991) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: