Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The study approaches the issue of control versus freedom in creative work. A high‐tech product development project was studied during its three year execution phase. Thirty engineers worked on the project, in three sub‐groups. The climate was measured on eleven occasions and the results fed back to the project group for common analysis. The climate was highly creative, even if it deteriorated somewhat at the end. The management of the project and the structure was loose. These organisational circumstances paved the way for a technologically advanced, spearhead, future‐directed but expensive product to come out. However, the customer wanted a less advanced and cheaper product. The goal of the customer had not been clearly communicated to the people in the project. The goal of the project leadership was to develop an advanced product for future applications as well. The goal corresponded to the needs, values and competencies of the project staff. According to the rule‐book for effective project management, the project was badly managed and it consequently became a failure. But from a creativity point of view, and in a longer time perspective, it became a success. A follow‐up three years later showed that the product had been applied in several new defence systems.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Göran Ekvall (1993) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: