Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This discussion reconsiders issues of educational accountability. To do so, I report on a qualitative case study of a public elementary school that identified how a model of educational accountability threatened to punish educators through a sophisticated network of surveillance. Data indicated that district personnel used standardized tests to monitor teachers in attempts to coerce them into accepting normalizing judgments of their practice. The study also described the surveillance within the school, including strategies by curriculum developers, reading facilitators, parents, and the principal to monitor teachers' work. The analysis examined the effects surveillance had on participants and described the ways teachers amplified the effects of surveillance in the school. The analysis rethinks such punitive accountability practices and suggests replacing them with opportunities for teacher education and teacher learning. Notes * University of Washington, Bothell, Box 358531, 18115 Campus Way NE, Bothell, WA 98011‐8246, USA. Email: ptwebb@uwb.edu Redwood Elementary and the names of teachers are pseudonyms. Sometimes described as organizational accountability or administrative accountability. Notable exceptions include Pignatelli (Citation2002) and Gleeson and Husbands (Citation2003). Also, see Williams vs State of California at www.ucla‐idea.org. At the time of this writing, 11 states had drafted legislation to either eliminate NCLB from its purview or to severely curtail its effects due to lack of funds needed to support its intent (see Seattle Times, Citation2004). Data surveillance is 'the collection of information about an identifiable individual [and organization], often from multiple sources, that can be assembled into a portrait of that person's activities' (Stanley & Steinhardt, Citation2003, p. 3). Other strategies include 'controlling the agenda' and 'mobilizing bias' so people's interests remain latent. I am aware that 'surveil' is not recognized as a word. However, I use it throughout the discussion, borrowing from Fraser (Citation1989), because it better signifies an intention to coerce. I also use the supposed gerund 'surveiling' and past participle 'surveiled' for their rhetorical benefits as well. Additional informationNotes on contributorsP. Taylor Webb Footnote* * University of Washington, Bothell, Box 358531, 18115 Campus Way NE, Bothell, WA 98011‐8246, USA. Email: ptwebb@uwb.edu
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
P. Taylor Webb (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: