Key result
Exercise referral schemes improve physical activity, blood pressure, BMI, and depression, despite conflicting cost-effectiveness.
Why the study?
Exercise referral schemes may help patients lead more active lifestyles, but their impact on patient activity/fitness, clinical outcomes, and cost-effectiveness needed evaluation.
Do exercise referral schemes improve patient activity/fitness, clinical outcomes, and cost-effectiveness?
Systematic Review (n=62,815)
Do exercise referral schemes improve patient activity/fitness, clinical outcomes, and cost-effectiveness?
Exercise referral schemes are an effective strategy to improve patient physical activity, cardiometabolic health, and mental health.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports broader clinical adoption for cardiometabolic and mental health gains; confirms benefits across large populations while leaving cost-effectiveness unresolved.
Exercise referral schemes (ERS) involving referrals from primary care providers to exercise programs and professionals may be a useful strategy for helping patients lead more active lifestyles. We performed an umbrella review to determine the impact of ERS on patient activity/fitness, clinical outcomes, and their cost-effectiveness. The review was pre-registered in Prospero (CRD42023443094) and conducted in July 2023. PRISMA reporting was followed. Our umbrella review screened 2129 citations with 12 studies meeting our inclusion criteria ( n = 8 meta-analyses) that included 110 unique individual studies of 62 815 unique participants. The average study quality was 8.9 ± 1.9 (out of 11). Studies examined patient physical activity or fitness ( n = 9/12), a clinical outcome ( n = 8/12), and/or cost-effectiveness ( n = 4/12). Earlier reviews observed that physical activity or fitness was unchanged following ERS, but more recent (post-2015), larger sample size studies observe low-to-moderate improvements. Recent reviews reported that ERS lowered blood pressure, body mass index, and depression. ERS cost-effectiveness was conflicting. Altogether our umbrella review of high-quality reviews with a low risk of bias demonstrated that although early work indicated null effects, more up-to-date reviews of ERS observe improved patient activity/fitness, cardiometabolic, and mental health. ERS are an effective strategy to improve patient health.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
O’Brien et al. (2024) conducted a systematic review in Patients referred from primary care (n=62,815). Exercise referral schemes was evaluated on Patient activity/fitness, clinical outcomes, and cost-effectiveness. Exercise referral schemes improved patient physical activity, fitness, blood pressure, BMI, and depression across 12 reviews including 62,815 participants, though cost-effectiveness was conflicting.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: