Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In the 1880s, a struggle between a teenage girl and her father attracted public attention. Maud Charlesworth, a daughter of an Anglican clergyman, became involved in the Salvation Army against her father's wish, and eventually married a son of 'General' William Booth. It was one of those subtle, day‐to‐day resistances which occur within a family, at the same time being a battle between the two 'religious family enterprises'. The contest was over ideas on gender, class, age, and the way to salvation, all of which the Rev. Charlesworth, as a clergyman as well as a father, had imparted to Maud. In this sense, a Victorian parsonage might be considered an excellent example of the gender/power structures that shaped middle‐class relationships. This article analyses the various discourses that Maud, her father, her mother, her sisters, the Salvation Army, and the Church of England utilised, in order to explore the complexity of family dynamics and the interface between gender, class and religion in the negotiation of family roles and identities. From the forms of rhetoric that she used, it will also reconsider the issue of 'separate spheres'. Acknowledgements I am grateful to Pam Cox, Annemarie Woodward, John Oliphant and two anonymous readers for Women's History Review for their encouragement and helpful comments. Notes [1] The Salvation Army at Geneva—a lamb among wolves, The Times, 19 February 1883, p. 4. [2] In Parliament, demands were made to ensure the safety of British subjects abroad, and the British consul in Geneva made a protest against the Swiss government. The Times, 15 February 1883, p. 5. Josephine Butler also condemned the treatment of the Salvationists by the Swiss authorities. Josephine Butler (1883) The Salvation Army in Switzerland (London: Dyer Brothers). [3] 'A Lamb among Wolves'; The Times, 20 February 1883, p. 9; Susan Fulton Welty (1961) Look Up and Hope!: the life of Maud Ballington Booth (New York: Thomas Nelson & Sons), p. 43. [4] In the 1870s–80s, there was a general concern about the sexual vulnerability of working‐class girls who might easily fall prey to upper‐ and middle‐ class libertines. See Judith R. Walkowitz (1994) City of Dreadful Delight: narratives of sexual danger in late‐Victorian London (London: Virago), pp. 88–93. [5] Samuel Beddome Charlesworth (1885) Sensational Religion; as resorted to in the system called the 'Salvation Army', in its influence upon the young, and in its effect upon the duties and claims of home life (Ipswich?: privately printed); Welty, Look Up and Hope!, pp. 41–44; 'A Lamb among Wolves'. [6] Samuel Charlesworth (1883) To the editor of The Times, The Times, 21 February, p. 12. [7] The Times, 21 February 1883, p. 9. [8] William Booth (1883) To the editor of The Times, The Times, 22 February, p. 5. [9] Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, p. 83. [10] Saint John Greer Ervine (1934) God's Soldier: General William Booth (London: William Heinemann), pp. 585–588; Roy Hattersley (2000) Blood and Fire: William and Catherine Booth and their Salvation Army (London: Abacus), pp. 296–300. [11] Pamela J. Walker (2001) Pulling the Devil's Kingdom Down: the Salvation Army in Victorian Britain (Berkeley: University of California Press). Diane Winston (2000) Red‐Hot and Righteous: the urban religion of the Salvation Army (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press) refers to Maud's Salvation Army work in the United States. [12] See Leonore Davidoff & Catherine Hall (1987) Family Fortunes: men and women of the English middle class 1780–1850 (London: Routledge), pp. 147–148. [13] Wives and daughters were expected to be incorporated into the profession of their husbands/fathers. Sean Gill (1994) Women and the Church of England: from the eighteenth century to the present (London: SPCK), p. 139. [14] For mothers' mixed message to their daughters, see Janet Oppenheim (1995) A Mother's Role, a Daughter's Duty: Lady Blanche Balfour, Eleanor Sidgwick, and feminist perspectives, Journal of British Studies, 34, pp. 196–232; Carol Dyhouse (1981) Girls Growing Up in Late Victorian and Edwardian England (London: Routledge); M. Jeanne Peterson (1989) Family, Love, and Work in the Lives of Victorian Gentlewomen (Bloomington: Indiana University Press). For brother–sister relationship, see Leonore Davidoff (1995) Where the Stranger Begins: the question of siblings in historical analysis, in Leonore Davidoff, Worlds Between: historical perspectives on gender and class (Cambridge: Polity Press); Valerie Sanders (2002) The Brother–Sister Culture in Nineteenth‐Century Literature: from Austen to Woolf (Basingstoke: Palgrave). [15] Sue Morgan (2002) Introduction, in Sue Morgan (Ed.) Women, Religion and Feminism in Britain, 1750–1900 (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan), pp. 9–16. Mathers shows the example of Josephine Butler, whose feminist political conviction, actually, derived from her evangelical faith. Helen Mathers (2002) Evangelicalism and Feminism: Josephine Butler, 1828–1906, in ibid. Anne Summers has introduced the idea of 'civil sphere', which includes religious and charitable activities within the true 'public'. Anne Summers (2000) Female Lives, Moral States: women, religion and public life in Britain 1800–1930 (Newbury: Threshold). About religious women who challenged male authorities, see Martha Vicinus (1985) Church Communities: sisterhoods and deaconesses' houses, in Martha Vicinus, Independent Women: work and community for single women 1850–1920 (London: Virago), pp. 46–84, and Susan Mumm (1999) Stolen Daughters, Virgin Mothers: Anglican sisterhoods in Victorian Britain (London: Leicester University Press). [16] Gileen Janes Yeo (1998) Some Paradoxes of Empowerment, in Eileen Janes Yeo (Ed.) Radical Femininity: women's self‐representation in the public sphere (Manchester: Manchester University Press), pp. 1–24. [17] Maud Ballington Booth (1994) A Rector's Daughter in Victorian England: memories of childhood and girlhood (Metairie, LA: Volunteers of America), p. 19. [18] Crockford's Clerical Directory, 1870, 1872, 1874, 1882; Clergy List, 1870, 1873; Booth, A Rector's Daughter, pp. 13, 16–17; Welty, Look Up and Hope!, pp. 15, 19; Samuel Beddome Charlesworth (1882) Memorials of a Blessed Life … a brief record of the work of Mrs. Maria Amelia Charlesworth (London: Seeley, Jackson & Halliday), p. 33. [19] See, for example, chapter two of Davidoff & Hall, Family Fortunes and Judith Rowbotham (1989) Good Girls Make Good Wives: guidance for girls in Victorian fiction (Oxford: Basil Blackwell). Such experience in parish charities gave daughters of clergymen opportunities to excavate and cultivate their hidden talents, especially in musical and theatrical performance, public speech, harmonising human relationships, leadership, ingenuity, organisation, and design. Midori Yamaguchi (2001) 'Unselfish' Desires: daughters of the Anglican clergy, 1830–1914 (Ph.D. thesis, University of Essex). [20] About the Mildmay Mission, see Alison M. Bucknall (1998) Martha's Work and Mary's Contemplation? The Women of the Mildmay Conference and the Keswick Convention 1856–1900, Studies in Church History, 34, pp. 405–420. [21] Charlesworth, Memorials; Booth, A Rector's Daughter, pp. 18–20; Welty, Look Up and Hope!, p. 29. [22] One of her Daughters (1921) The Life of Florence L. Barclay: a study in personality (London: Putnam's), pp. 55, 57–58. [23] In the 1830s–40s, the Pattison sisters, influenced by their brother, secretly practised high‐church liturgy in the rectory of their evangelical father. Jo Manton (1971) Sister Dora: the life of Dorothy Pattison (London: Methuen), pp. 34–54. About childhood religious experiences, see also Mary Clare Hewlett Martin (2000) Children and Religion in Walthamstow and Layton, c.1740–c.1870 (Ph.D. thesis, University of London). [24] Booth, A Rector's Daughter, pp. 10–11. [25] Ibid., pp. 19, 44–46; One of her Daughters, The Life of Florence L. Barclay, pp. 27–29, 42–43, 55–58; Charlesworth, Sensational, p. 113. [26] Maud B. Booth (1894) Beneath Two Flags: a study in mercy and help methods (New York: Hunt and Eaton), p. vii. [27] Booth, A Rector's Daughter, p. 67. [28] Ibid., p. 68. [29] Ibid., pp. 64–67. [30] Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, p. 106. [31] Ibid., p. 5; Welty, Look Up and Hope!, pp. 29–30, 33–34. [32] Stuart Mews (1988) The General and the Bishops: alternative response to dechristianisation, in T. R. Gourvish & Alan O'Day (Eds) Later Victorian Britain: 1867–1900 (London: Macmillan); Norman H. Murdoch (1986) The Salvation Army and the Church of England, 1882–1883, Historical Magazine of the Protestant Episcopal Church, 55(1), pp. 31–55; Randall T. Davidson (1882) The Methods of the Salvation Army, Contemporary Review, 42, p. 190; Bramwell Booth (1925) Echoes and Memories (London: Hodder & Stoughton), pp. 59–70; Harold Begbie (1926) Life of William Booth: the founder of the Salvation Army (London: Macmillan), pp. 10–19; Hattersley, Blood and Fire, pp. 261–284. [33] Edward Benson manuscript diary, 9 June 1882, cited in Mews, 'The General and the Bishops', p. 222. [34] Women Who Work, Pall Mall Gazette, 2 May 1884. [35] Cited in Andrew Mark Eason (2003) Women in God's Army: gender and equality in the early Salvation Army (Waterloo, ON: Wilfrid Laurier University Press), p. xi. Eason argues that women's experiences of the Salvation Army did not, nevertheless, necessarily reflect such official statements. [36] Maria Amelia Charlesworth (1874) Words of Truth and Trust: being addresses at the meetings of the Association of Female Workers, held after the Mildmay Conference, 1874. I. By Mrs Charlesworth. II. By Mrs Pearsall Smith (London: S. W. Partridge), p. 8. [37] Welty, Look Up and Hope!, p. 29. About Butler, see Mathers, 'Evangelicalism' and Jane Jordan (2001) Josephine Butler (London: John Murray). For the contest against women speaking to mixed audiences, see also Jenny Daggers (2001) The Victorian Female Civilising Mission and Women's Aspirations towards Priesthood in the Church of England, Women's History Review, 10(4), pp. 660–663. Beverly Mayne Kienzle & Pamela J. Walker (Eds) (1998) Women Preachers and Prophets through Two Millennia of Christianity (Berkeley: University of California Press) show diverse ways Christian women have 'preached' in history. Walker's article in this anthology, above all, deals with the case of Catherine Booth, the founder of the Salvation Army: Pamela J. Walker (1998) A Chaste and Fervid Eloquence: Catherine Booth and the ministry of women in the Salvation Army, in ibid. DeVries reveals the connection between Salvation Army female preachers and early twentieth‐century feminists. Suffragettes, in particular, borrowed the languages, motifs and styles from the Salvation Army. Jacqueline R. deVries (1998) Transforming the Pulpit: preaching and prophecy in the British women's suffrage movement, in ibid. [38] Walker, 'A Chaste and Fervid Eloquence'. [39] One of her Daughters, The Life of Florence L. Barclay, p. 97. [40] Ibid. Later she was to be known as the author of a million‐seller novel, The Rosary. [41] Booth, A Rector's Daughter, p. 68. [42] Mrs Charlesworth to Maud Charlesworth, 25 July 1881, cited in Charlesworth, Sensational, p. 10. [43] Mrs Charlesworth to Maud Charlesworth, 1 October 1881, cited in ibid., pp. 10–11. [44] Booth, A Rector's Daughter, pp. 64–68, 70; Welty, Look Up and Hope!, pp. 33–36, 38. [45] Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, p. 14. [46] Rocks ahead for the Salvationists, Saturday Review, 54, 19 August 1882, p. 243. See also Davidson, 'The Methods of the Salvation Army'. [47] Charlesworth, Sensational Relgion, pp. 13–31; Welty, Look Up and Hope!, pp. 38–40; Charlesworth, 'To the editor of the Times', 21 February. [48] It is actually Luke 9: 62. Booth, A Rector's Daughter, pp. 73–74. [49] The Rev. Charlesworth to Maud Charlesworth, 28 November 1882; cited in Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, pp. 31–32. [50] Ibid., pp. 31, 52, 80. [51] Davidoff et al. point out that the boundary between childhood and adulthood was determined by class rather than age, and a domestic servant of fourteen or fifteen was dressed and treated as a grown‐up, while the daughter of the house of a similar age, as a child. See Leonore Davidoff, Megan Doolittle, Janet Fink & Katherine Holden (1999) The Family Story: blood, contract and intimacy, 1830–1960 (London: Longman), pp.168–169. Middle‐class ideas on the age of adulthood were also reflected in the campaign to raise the legal age of 'consent' from twelve to thirteen in 1875 and sixteen in 1885. [52] Booth, A Rector's Daughter, pp. 76–77. [53] Catherine Booth to the Rev. Charlesworth, 24 February 1883, cited in Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, p. 49. [54] Catherine Booth to the Rev. Charlesworth, 30 March 1883, cited in ibid., p. 81. [55] Booth, A Rector's Daughter, p. 82. [56] The Rev. Charlesworth to Maud Charlesworth, 24 February 1883, cited in Charlesworth, Sensational Relgion, pp. 53–54. [57] Ibid., p. 103. [58] Maud Charlesworth to the Rev. Charlesworth, 24 November 1883, cited in ibid., p. 100. [59] Mumm, Stolen Daughters, pp. 173–190; Vicinus, 'Church Communities', pp. 51–52. See also Michael Hill (1973) The Religious Order: a study of virtuoso religion and its legitimation in the nineteenth‐century Church of England (London: Heinemann), pp. 299–300. [60] Randall Thomas Davidson & William Benham (1891) Life of Archibald Campbell Tait, Archbishop of Canterbury (London: Macmillan), I, pp. 467–469. Kollar points out that Archibald Tait's emphasis on the integrity of family emanated from the deaths of his five young daughters from scarlet fever. Rene Kollar (2003) A Death in the Family: Bishop Archibald Campbell Tait, the rights of parents, and Anglican sisterhoods in the diocese of London, Journal of Religious History, 27(2), pp. 198–214. [61] Official Report of the 18th Annual Church Congress … at Sheffield 1878 (1879) (London), p. 362, cited in Catherine M. Prelinger (1986) The Female Diaconate in the Anglican Church: what kind of ministry for women, in Gail Malmgreen (Ed.) Religion in the Lives of English Women, 1760–1930 (Bloomington: Indiana University Press), pp. 178–179. [62] Annie Charlesworth to Maud Charlesworth, 8 February [March?] 1883, cited in Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, p. 62. [63] John Milton (1674) Paradise Lost, IV, 299. [64] Victorian girls' fiction shows that women's self‐denial was expected to 'be kept within reasonable bounds'. See Rowbotham, Good Girls, pp. 57–58. [65] Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, p. 24. [66] The Times, 21 February 1883, p. 9; Frances Power Cobbe (1882) The Last Revival, The Contemporary Review, 42, p. 183; Davidson, 'The Methods of the Salvation Army', pp. 192–193. [67] Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, p. 72. [68] Lucy Bland (1995) Banishing the Beast: English feminism and sexual morality, 1885–1914 (London: Penguin), pp. 55–60. [69] Janet Oppenheim (1991) Shattered Nerves: doctors, patients, and depression in Victorian England (Oxford: Oxford University Press), pp. 196–200. [70] About the shame experienced by the family in the cases of mental or nervous disorder, see Charlotte MacKenzie (1992) Psychiatry for the Rich: a history of Ticehurst Private Asylum (London: Routledge), pp. 101–102. [71] Catherine Booth to the Rev. Charlesworth, 24 February 1883, cited in Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, pp. 47–50. [72] Ibid., p. 56. [73] Ibid., p. 60. [74] Samuel Charlesworth, To the editor of The Times, The Times, 24 February 1883, p. 9; Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, pp. 69–70. [75] Annie Charlesworth to Maud Charlesworth, 8 February [March?] 1883, cited in ibid., pp. 63–64. [76] Ibid., p. 72. [77] Ibid., p. 25. [78] Ibid., p. 71. [79] Ibid., pp. 72–73, 75. [80] The Rev. Charlesworth to Catherine Booth, 15 March 1883, cited in ibid., pp. 73–74. [81] The Rev. Charlesworth to Catherine Booth, 23 and 31 March 1883, cited in ibid., pp. 73–77. [82] Ibid., p. 77. [83] War Cry, 21 February 1883. [84] Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, p. 80. [85] The Rev. Charlesworth to William Booth, 8 October 1883, cited in ibid., p. 92. [86] Ibid., pp. 91–92. Florence and her husband supported Maud, and attended her wedding. [87] The Times, 15 October 1883, p. 6. [88] Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, p. 92. [89] The Rev. Charlesworth to Mrs Booth, 13 October 1883, cited in ibid., pp. 93–97. Davidoff and Hall have suggested that illness, along with religiosity, was a way in which daughters have exercised 'passive resistance' against parental authority. Davidoff & Hall, Family Fortunes, p. 334. About debate on the extent to which hysteria might have been a form of female rebellion and protest, see Barbara Harrison (1995) Women and Health, in June Purvis (Ed.) (1995) Women's History Britain, 1850–1945 (London: UCL Press), p. 168. [90] Booth, A Rector's Daughter, p. 85. [91] Ibid. [92] Ibid., p. 85; Charlesworth, Sensational Religion, p. 106. [93] The Rev. Charlesworth to William Booth, 12 October 1883, cited in ibid., pp. 95–96. [94] Ibid., pp.90, 106–107; Booth, A Rector's Daughter, p. 90; Welty, Look Up and Hope!, p. 51. [95] Winston, Red‐Hot and Righteous, pp. 44–95. Welty, Look Up and Hope!, pp. 70–115. [96] Ibid., pp. 93–94. [97] Ibid., pp. 116–125, 155, 244–259. [98] Ibid., pp. 70ff. Additional informationNotes on contributorsMidori Yamaguchi Midori Yamaguchi is an Associate Professor at Daito Bunka University, Japan. Her research interests include women's agency, opportunities and identities in relation to their fathers' occupation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Midori Yamaguchi (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: