Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In modern humanities, the deep interest in the linguistic study of virtual communication is not contingent. In particular, discussions on popular science Telegram channels provide an opportunity to study the dynamics of participants’ involvement in a dialogue, which, thanks to the explication of objections and responses to them, shifts from «vertical» (from more knowledgeable person to less knowledgeable) to «horizontal». The empirical materials of the study were comments on Telegram channels on publications explaining new scientific ideas (Bluzhdayushchij Nerv and QWERTY). The purpose of the article is to analyze dynamics of the speech structure composing the participants’ semantic position in the discussion. The subject of our consideration is a disputants’ speech behavior which is explicated in discrepancy between semantic and communicative positions. The study uses a dialogic analysis method allowing to consider the "field of involvement" in the media as a stimulating remark, and the subsequent discussion being the "field of engagement" as a speech response in the form of a polylogical interaction of semantic positions. Each semantic position is considered in the form of a structure including denotative, modus and communicative components. Via this approach, in discussions, it has been possible to see different cognitive and communicative objection forms. Namely, it became clear that in the field of involvement, an objection provokes a discussion, drawing other participants into the interaction; in the field of engagement, a discussion continues by expanding the uncertainty in the objection, so a discussion development follows up. Subsequently, a discussion is supported by questions, assessments, subtext, etc. It is revealed that the verbal deployment of an objection has an interactive structure and includes not only an act of demonstrating a discrepancy of views, but also acts of expressing doubt, comparison, contradiction, support for an objection, critical assessment, etc. The novelty of the research is in exposing a variety of cognitive and communicative forms of polemicists’ speech behavior.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Дускаева et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: