This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
As the population of the United States continues to grow and communities become more diverse, it is becoming increasingly critical to identify and address health care disparities. Now more than ever, the medical community is recognizing the importance of diversity, equity, and inclusion to both our profession and the patients we serve. Prior research demonstrates a lack of diversity in medicine and an even greater need for diversity, equity, and inclusion in surgical subspecialties.1 A growing body of literature corroborates that these findings are relevant to the field of plastic surgery.2 Contributing to the ongoing lack of diversity in plastic surgery are barriers to entry throughout the pipeline—that is, among other things, the need for early exposure to the field, high productivity in research, a stellar academic record, and continued mentorship required to successfully match in plastic surgery. Although significant obstacles exist, medical schools and residency programs have continued to develop strategies to improve minority representation in the field. In this article, the authors provide a brief description of a mentorship program they developed to improve diversity, equity, and inclusion in plastic surgery.3 Invited participants included medical students who identified as racially underrepresented in medicine, those of diverse sexual backgrounds, first-generation low-income students, and those who do not have a plastic surgery residency program associated with their medical school. Program requirements included quarterly one-to-one meetings with a resident/faculty member in plastic surgery, involvement in a research project, and participation in a plastic surgery bootcamp held yearly at the authors’ home institution. A participant survey administered before beginning the program and repeated after completion was used to assess whether stated objectives were met. We commend the authors for their efforts to create solutions that increase diversity, equity, and inclusion in plastic surgery, and for their success in implementing this program at their institution. Notably, this work is remarkable because it attempts to address, rather than highlight, known limitations to diversity in plastic surgery. Among the most vital components to improving diversity, equity, and inclusion in plastic surgery are early exposure and mentorship of underrepresented minorities.4 As evidenced by the overwhelmingly positive participant ratings and selected comments found in the article, this initiative accomplishes these goals. Although laudable, it is important to recognize that this is but one strategy to address the field’s complex need, and other approaches should be explored and encouraged. Specifically, virtual subinternships and minority scholarship programs have recently emerged as additional avenues to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion and establish mentorship. Common critiques of such programs highlight the inability to capture all students desiring to participate. Although several factors including limited resources and availability of mentors contribute to this, we believe that each mentored student serves as an opportunity for progress. As the adage suggests, we should not allow perfection to become the enemy of good. In addition, it is worth noting that initiatives to improve diversity, equity, and inclusion undertaken by integrated plastic surgery programs are of great benefit not only to applicants, but to programs as well. Research on match data in plastic surgery demonstrates that students are far more likely to match at institutions they have previously interacted with.5 Therefore, programs that establish initiatives to improve diversity, equity, and inclusion create an opportunity to recruit remarkable individuals who might not otherwise have been considered. The U.S. Census Bureau projects that 50% of all Americans will belong to a minority group by 2044. At a time when health care reform, social progress, and the desire to address longstanding health care disparities intersect, we find great opportunity to develop initiatives that improve on a longstanding issue in society. Although underrepresentation has been documented in every field of medicine, we believe that plastic surgery is uniquely positioned to affect this change, as our particular field regularly demonstrates leadership and innovation.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Atia et al. (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: