Key result
Opt-out framing with active outreach yields ~3.6-fold higher trial enrollment in PAD patients.
Why the study?
Direct outreach is an efficient trial recruitment method, but the effect of different strategies on enrollment fraction and protocol completion is uncertain.
Does opt-out email framing with active telephone outreach improve trial enrollment fraction compared to traditional opt-in email framing in adult patients with peripheral artery disease contacted for a physical activity RCT?
RCT (n=5,176)
Investigator-blinded (coordinators and participants unblinded)
Randomized 7:1 initially, then 3:1 (opt-in vs opt-out)
No
Does opt-out email framing with active telephone outreach improve trial enrollment fraction compared to traditional opt-in email framing in adult patients with peripheral artery disease contacted for a physical activity RCT?
In a direct-to-participant randomized trial of patients with peripheral artery disease, opt-out email framing combined with active telephone outreach increased the trial enrollment fraction more than threefold compared to passive opt-in email outreach without compromising protocol completion.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Opt-out email with telephone outreach boosts PAD trial enrollment; extends efficient direct-to-participant recruitment methods in cardiovascular research.
Directly contacting eligible participants with an offer to join a randomized clinical trial (RCT) is an efficient recruitment method, but the effect of different outreach strategies on enrollment fraction and completion of the trial protocol is uncertain. In a study within a trial (SWAT) of an RCT testing a physical activity intervention in patients with peripheral artery disease, eligible patients were randomized to receive an email with an invitation to join the study and a link to the trial's online platform ("opt-in") or to receive an email framing participation as part of the standard of care followed by telephone outreach from a study coordinator ("opt-out"). Among 5176 participants contacted by unsolicited email (3909 opt-in, 1267 opt-out), enrollment fraction was 1.0% in the opt-in arm (n = 39) versus 3.6% in the opt-out arm (n = 45) (OR 3.65, 95% CI 2.37-5.64); there were no significant differences between opt-in and opt-out participants in the rate of completion of trial protocol steps. This SWAT of recruitment strategies demonstrates the potential for opt-out framing and active outreach to increase enrollment fraction without compromising protocol completion in direct-to-participant RCTs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Shah et al. (2025) conducted an RCT in Peripheral Artery Disease (PAD) (n=5,176). Opt-out email framing with active telephone outreach vs. Opt-in email framing (passive email invitation only) was evaluated on Enrollment fraction (number of patients enrolled divided by total contacted) (OR 3.65, 95% CI 2.37-5.64, p=<0.001). Opt-out framing with active telephone outreach increased trial enrollment fraction to 3.6% compared to 1.0% with opt-in framing in patients with PAD.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: