This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Development of the Engineering Classroom Learning Observation ProtocolDespite the continuous efforts, increasing K-12 students’ access to and performance in STEMsubjects is still a challenge. K-12 engineering education brings a new perspective to teachingSTEM subjects. However, while some research shows engineering education supports studentSTEM learning outcomes, others suggest lack of significant gains in student learning. One of thechallenges is that while there had been studies examining the relationship between curriculumused and student learning outcomes, few studies looked at how these learning outcomes arelinked to specific classroom practices. In other words, are there specific types of engineeringteaching practices (re-design projects, new design projects, projects with societal connections,projects with competitive aspects, etc.) that result in different types of learning outcomes? Ourintended long-term goal is to study the alignment between K-12 engineering curricula, theimplementation of these curricula, and the resulting student learning outcomes. However, as afirst step, what is needed is a robust and validated classroom observation protocol that can helpdistinguish differences in instructional approaches and inform the discrepancies in literature onstudent learning. The purpose of this paper is to describe the development of the EngineeringClassroom Learning Observation Protocol (EcLO Protocol). The development of the protocolstarted by reviewing the K-12 STEM standards and NAE reports on K-12 engineering education.We also conducted a content analysis of prominent engineering curricula such as Engineering isElementary and Project Lead the Way to identify diverse ways engineering is taught in theclassroom. In addition, published and validated classroom observation protocols such asReformed Teaching Observation protocol (RTOP) are used as models. In its current form, EcLOis a theory-driven protocol with sufficient content and construct validity. Future research isneeded to establish its concurrent validity by comparing the observation scores and studentlearning outcomes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dringenberg et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: