This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Welcome to this first issue of Nursing in Critical Care for 2022, and our new editorial style of introducing the journal's collection of papers. In October, this year, the British Association of Critical Care Nurses will mark their first joint conference; a collaborative event with the Irish Association of Critical Care Nurses. The conference theme of ‘Critical Care Across the World: Breaking Down Barriers’ provides an ideal platform to show our international unity, especially as the COVID-19 pandemic remains a global health concern and a persistent challenge for nursing in critical care. We are pleased to open this issue with an editorial by Tume et al.1 on how to write a good abstract for review by a conference scientific committee. We hope this helpful guidance inspires you to showcase your contribution to improving the outcomes and experiences of critical care, as a conference delegate, and through a write-up of the conference paper for submission to an academic journal. Nursing in critical care requires different forms of evidence for the holistic patient and family care,2 for example, knowledge from both the physical and social sciences. Our themed topic within this issue is a focus on qualitative research; a form of inquiry commonly used in the social sciences to understand concepts, opinions, or experiences,3 and to gain insights into people's feelings and thoughts.4 Data collection is usually context-bound and may be referred to as naturalistic inquiry5 or real-world research.6 A particular value of qualitative research reports, therefore, is the potential for readers to identify with and learn from the meanings and interpretations represented in the research. The papers within this issue comprise nine qualitative studies reporting primary research,7-15 a meta-synthesis of qualitative research to generate new insights and understanding of critically ill patients' experiences,16 together with an editorial17 and three quantitative studies18-20 that uphold the contribution of measurement to critical care research and practice. In contrast to findings arrived at by means of quantification and statistical analysis, qualitative research is designed to answer questions about the why, what and how of phenomena,21 thus contributing to the understanding of reasons behind the facts. For example, of relevance to the environment of the intensive care unit, studies have investigated the psychological impact of COVID-19 on frontline health care workers, including stress and anxiety measurements, and examined staff experiences to provide deeper personal insights and understandings of the problem.22 Qualitative research can also inform quantitative studies, as evidenced in the study in this issue by Madar et al.12 who designed a questionnaire based on published research and a previously conducted qualitative study. Qualitative research provides a rich pool of methodological approaches from which to choose,23 each with a unique purpose, and underlying philosophical tenets and assumptions. It is important to ensure that the right research design is used to answer the question posed24 and to justify the choice of approach and methods.25 Like all recipes, the ingredients arguably affect the quality of the end product. Of course, modifications may be made at the design stage, or if the need arises during implementation, but with the caveat of ensuring that the research plan remains a cohesive whole.26 Congruence and consistency, in relation to both the ways in which qualitative research is conducted and reported, are critical to the integrity and contribution of qualitative research.23 Cypress26 and Bradbury-Jones et al.23 individually offer a resourceful framework for understanding the traditional methodologies (e.g. ethnography, grounded theory, and phenomenology) and interrelated methods for qualitative inquiry. We also acknowledge the work of Thorne's interpretive description27 and the exploratory-descriptive qualitative approach to health research by Hunter et al.28 which serve as appropriate alternative methodologies for developing nursing knowledge. A selection of papers in this issue also provide examples of research to explore a particular topic, based on the principles of qualitative research design. Various conceptual frameworks are also available for qualitative evidence synthesis, again requiring careful selection and justification dependent on the nature and purpose of reviewing secondary research. Dyar29 acknowledges that qualitative research offers some unique challenges, and in our experience, methodological shortfalls and/or superficial accounts of the research process can impact the quality and suitability of research reports for publication. Qualitative analysis is often an under-reported section within manuscripts, lacking transparency with regard to the process and outcomes. At the same time, the desire to represent participant voices can affect the overall word limit and create imbalance. To assist aspiring authors, we have recently updated our journal author guidelines, offering up to 4500 words for a qualitative research report (excluding references), and signposting readers to three good examples of qualitative studies (with and without a traditional theoretical focus, respectively) that may be helpful to your research or when preparing a manuscript for this journal. The EQUATOR Network30 promotes useful reporting tools for primary and secondary qualitative research that may also serve as a checklist at the design and planning stage. When reporting qualitative research, we encourage the use of language in keeping with the qualitative tradition, such as findings (not results), the disclosure of issues surrounding the researcher's reflexivity,31 and contextual detail and clarity to strengthen transferability of the research findings. Demonstrating the trustworthiness of qualitative inquiry32 and how this was achieved is essential to providing journal peer reviewers and subsequent readers sound assurance about the quality of your research and its contribution to evidence-based nursing in critical care. We hope the editorials and research reports in this issue provide guidance and inspiration as you plan and prepare for the new year ahead. Together with the editors, we wish all our readers a healthy, successful and rewarding New Year.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Walker et al. (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: