Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In the 1985 case of Wong v. Tenneco, Inc.,' the California Supreme Court invalidated a contract by applying Mexican law despite the fact that both parties were California citizens and the contract had been made and performed in California.In reaching its decision the court applied not the doctrine of governmental interest analysis, California's approach to choice of law questions for the last twenty years, but the older doctrine of comity of nations. 2 In the same year two other state high courts reached choice-of-law decisions by using a modern choice-of-law approach and then applying the older public policy exception to the comity doctrine. 3At one time comity and the public policy exception rationales governed choice-of-law decisions. 4In contrast to modern systematic approaches, however, the older doctrines lack both analytical structure and standards for determining when and how they should be applied.'The traditional lex loci choice-of-law rules, around which both comity and its public policy exception developed, have increasingly been replaced by modern policy-oriented choice-of-law approaches. 6These 1985 cases, decided by each state's highest court in three different states adopting modern approaches, present a strange and unexplained blend of old and new approaches to choice-of-law questions.They could be interpreted as signaling a retreat from their states' modem approaches.Certainly, they evidence a need to define the analytical relationship between modern choice-of-law approaches and the comity and public policy doctrines.This Comment explores the backgrounds of the comity and public policy doctrines, reviews the development of modern choice-of-law techniques, and evaluates the place of the comity and public policy doctrines against this modern backdrop.This Comment argues that the criticisms of these doctrines as vague and lacking objective standards are well 1986]
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Holly Sprague (1986) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: