Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Surprisingly little research explores whether congressional staffers systematically influence legislative agendas, or whether the descriptive representation of groups like Latinos on congressional staffs shapes policy responsiveness to group interests. I address these questions through an ordinary least squares (OLS) regression analysis of factors associated with the prevalence of Latino interests on legislative agendas during the 110th Congress (2007–2008). Results show the proportions of representatives' legislative agendas that represented Latino interests, especially through symbolic initiatives, were positively associated with the representation of Latinos on their legislative staffs. These findings suggest Latino representation on legislative staffs enhances congressional policy responsiveness to Latinos. Keywords: Latino/a politicslegislativerepresentationcongressional staff Notes The motivation for this study springs from questions raised by my observations as a congressional staffer. As a former APSA congressional fellow in the office of a prominent Latino congressman, and assistant to his Congressional Hispanic Caucus liaison, I spent substantial time working on "Latino issues," and observing and thinking about the roles of Latino representatives in representing Latinos. My interactions with congressional staffers, many of whom were Latino, raised similar questions about whether staffer ethnicity affects representation or the legislative process. Replication data will be made available on request by the author. Observations of sponsorships by Charles Norwood (R-GA), who died in February 2007, and who did not substantially participate in legislative activities during the 110th Congress, are not considered in this analysis. Organizations representing Latino policy interests do so with relative consistency regarding policy priorities and positions. Organization websites consulted for this research include those of the National Hispanic Leadership Agenda, Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund, the League of United Latin American Citizens, the National Council of La Raza, the Cuban American National Council, and the Puerto Rican Legal Defense and Education Fund. Clearly, the interests of Latinos are not monolithic, and substantial variation characterizes Latino attitudes and interests both within and across subgroups. While my judgments largely conform to ideological positions on Latinos issues, the designations of Latino Interest and Anti-Latino Interest reflect something like a "majority consensus" among Latinos on these issues. Additionally, because the definition employed in this analysis is broad and, therefore, likely to conflate policies that affect Latinos to different degrees, and vary regarding the strength and distribution of Latino preferences, one may reasonably question whether all Latino Interest Bills are "equal." The most likely result is that this inclusive coding scheme stacks the deck in favor of null findings. Still, I believe it offers a valid, reliable, and replicable measure of legislative efforts to provide policy responsiveness to Latinos. Scholars often use count models, such as negative binomial regression models, to explore bill sponsorship behaviors (Anderson, Box-Steffensmeier, and Sinclair Citation2003), and logistic regression models of bill characteristics to explore legislative agenda-setting (Krutz Citation2005). Because representatives' legislative activities vary wildly (numbers of bill sponsorships in the data examined here range from 2 for Bill Young (R-FL) to 92 for Representative Sheila Jackson Lee (D-TX)), bill counts are a problematic measure for assessing legislative agenda-setting. Because staffers work within offices, it makes better sense to assess their influence on individual legislative agendas than the institutional agenda as a whole. It should be noted, however, that other methodological approaches using identical models were explored, including negative binomial regression to examine counts of Latino Interest Bills sponsored, and logistic regression to estimate the likelihood that average bills addressed Latino interest issues. These models revealed results for coefficient size and significance that were comparable to those presented in the manuscript, suggesting that the findings are robust. The common Spanish surnames were: Garcia, Martinez, Rodriguez, Lopez, Hernandez, Gonzalez, Perez, Sanchez, Rivera, Ramirez, Torres, and Gonzales. The common non-Spanish surnames were: Smith, Johnson, Williams, Brown, Jones, Davis, Miller, Wilson, Anderson, Moore, Taylor, and Thomas. The six Latino representatives who did not employ a Latino on their legislative staffs during the period in question were Jose Serrano (D-NY), Grace Napolitano (D-CA), Jim Costa (D-CA), Devin Nunes (R-CA), Ed Pastor (D-AZ) and Henry Cuellar (D-TX). Twenty-six Latino representatives (22 Democrats and four Republicans) served during the 110th Congress. Because the Congressional Hispanic Caucus (CHC) recognized two Democrats of Portuguese descent as full members, these representatives, and one Republican representative of Portuguese descent, are included in this count. Separate analyses of Latino interest agenda-setting (not shown) demonstrated that the effects of Latino representation in each non-legislative staff category listed here on Latino Interest Bill sponsorship were insignificant, as was the effect of an interaction term that multiplied Latino non-Legislative Staff*Latino Rep. This variable is a dichotomous variable. Co-linearity between party and ideology (measured by DW-NOMINATE scores) prevented the inclusion of the latter in these models. Race and gender variables were coded dichotomously by the author. The percentage of district population that was urban was examined in separate analyses (not shown), but did not affect results significantly or substantially alter the magnitude or significance of other coefficients. Latino and Black population data are measured as population proportions, and derived from the US Census, American Community Survey estimates for 2005. Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) diagnostics demonstrate that correlation between Latino population and Latino representative does not pose a stability problem in the analyses presented. Data on Constituency Conservatism reflect the percentage of the vote received by President Bush, and was obtained from the Almanac of American Politics, 2006, by Michael Barone and Richard Cohen Citation(2005).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Walter Clark Wilson (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: