Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article exposes some of the weaknesses of the social semiotic concept of 'visual modality' in analysing the perceived truthfulness of images, by contrasting it with the more productive notion of 'authenticity'. Using three autobiographical comics as examples, I argue that Kress and van Leeuwen's notion of modality is unable to capture adequately the complex relations that can pertain between images and reality, as it places too much emphasis on picture-immanent stylistic markers and neglects the performed element of truthfulness. In the case of autobiographical comics, 'producer-oriented' forms of authenticity seem to play a more important role than stylistic features in determining whether or not visual representations are likely to be seen as truthful. Notes [1] In an interview with Hillary Chute (2006 Chute, H. 2006. Gothic revival. Old father, old artificer: Tracing the roots of Alison Bechdel's exhilarating new 'tragicomic', Fun home. In The Village Voice http://www.villagevoice.com/2006-07-04/books/gothic-revival (http://www.villagevoice.com/2006-07-04/books/gothic-revival) (Accessed: 6 July 2009). [Google Scholar]), Bechdel admits that this painstaking method may reflect her slightly obsessive character and a lingering sense that she cannot quite trust her own perceptions. I am grateful to Thierry Groensteen for drawing my attention to this article. [2] The increasing awareness of the blurred boundaries between autobiography and fiction are reflected in the terms that are now commonly used to refer to the genre, with scholars often preferring to talk about 'life writing' (e.g. Adams 2000 Adams, T. D. 2000. Light writing and life writing: Photography in autobiography, Chapel Hill and London: University of North Carolina Press. [Google Scholar]) or 'autofiction' (e.g. Masschelein 2008 Masschelein, A. 2008. Foreword to the special edition autofiction and/in image – autofiction visuelle II. Image&Narrative: Online Magazine of the Visual Narrative 22: n.p. http://www.imageandnarrative.be/autofiction2/masschelein.html (http://www.imageandnarrative.be/autofiction2/masschelein.html) (Accessed: 2 July 2009). [Google Scholar]). [3] O'Toole (1994 O'Toole, M. 1994. The language of displayed art, London: Leicester University Press. [Google Scholar], 188) defines visual modality as the 'degrees of verisimilitude or lifelikeness, ranging through authentic/ironic/fantastic'. His suggestion that modality can be systematised as 'life-like', 'exaggerated', 'attenuated' and 'abstract' (37) appears to be somewhat similar to Kress and van Leeuwen's distinction between four coding orientations, although he does not elaborate on this. [4] In the original: 'wobei das vermeintlich stillose Darstellungsformat aus der gezielt initiierten oppositionallen Struktur von (gestaltetem) Text und (subversivem) Nicht-Text seine Authentizität zieht' (Wortmann 2003 Wortmann, V. 2003. Authentisches Bild und authentisierende Form, Cologne: Herbert von Halem. [Google Scholar], 217). [5] In van Leeuwen (2005 van Leeuwen, T. 2005. Introducing social semiotics, London and New York: Routledge. [Google Scholar], 167), the dimension of 'representation' is referred to as 'articulation of detail'. [6] Bateman's (2008 Bateman, J. A. 2008. Multimodality and genre: A foundation for the systematic analysis of multimodal documents, Houndmills and New York: Palgrave Macmillan. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]) recent publication develops social semiotics further by placing much more emphasis on the importance of genre conventions. [7] In an interview about the film version of Persepolis, Satrapi explicitly refers to her aim of reflecting her own perceptions: 'I'm just talking about what I've seen with my own eyes' (Bochenski 2008 Bochenski, M. 2008. Citizen Marji. Little White Lies: Truth & Movies, 16(2): 34–7. [Google Scholar], 37). [8] A similar strategy of authentication has been discussed in relation to Art Spiegelman's comic-book rendering of his parents' experience of surviving the Holocaust, Maus: A Survivor's Tale, which casts all the characters as animal figures (Cioffi 2001 Cioffi, F. L. 2001. "Disturbing comics: The disjunction of word and image in the comics of Andrzej Mlecyko, Ben Katchor, R. Crumb, and Art Spiegelman". In The language of comics: Word and image, Edited by: Varnum, R. and Gibbons, C. T. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi. [Google Scholar]; Kannenberg 2001 Kannenberg, G. Jr. 2001. "'I looked just like Rudolph Valentino': Identity and representation in Maus". In The graphic novel, Edited by: Baetens, J. Leuven: Leuven University Press. [Google Scholar]): 'Art Spiegelman is a cartoonist and his father is a Holocaust survivor, but neither is a mouse made of ink, even though Maus asks us to believe that they are, and the book succeeds when we acquiesce. "Realism" thus becomes a conspiracy between writer and reader, not an essential relation between certain texts and the world of experience' (Witek 1989 Witek, J. 1989. Comic books as history: The narrative art of Jack Jackson, Art Spiegelman, and Harvey Pekar, Jackson and London: University Press of Mississippi. [Google Scholar], 115–6).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elisabeth El Refaie (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: