Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Games of the New Emerging Forces (GANEFO) have previously been highlighted as both the most obvious instance of the politicisation of international sport, and as the biggest challenge to the International Olympic Committee's domination of international sport, particularly among the newly-independent and decolonising nations of Asia and Africa.1 1. See Gitersos, ‘The Sporting Scramble for Africa’. However, despite the avowedly political nature of GANEFO as both a sporting event and an organisation, to date there does not exist a clear analysis of the internal politics of GANEFO and their role in the organisation's ultimate demise. The Second GANEFO, scheduled to take place in Cairo in 1967 never took place, ultimately leading to the death of GANEFO. This article seeks to fill a gap in the explanation of the demise of GANEFO, by examining the internal politics of GANEFO as told by declassified documents from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People's Republic of China. In their discussion of the rise and fall of GANEFO, Rusli Lutan and Fan Hong wrote that, ‘Cairo announced it could not hold GANEFO II in 1966 for financial reasons. The PRC was in the turmoil of the Cultural Revolution and had no intention of supporting the Egyptian initiative.'2 2. Rusli Lutan and Fan, ‘The Politicisation of Sport’, 436. However, the political tensions that existed within GANEFO from the outset meant that Egypt's willingness, rather than its capacity, to host the Second GANEFO was in doubt from almost as soon as its selection as host city was announced, and these were intimately connected to the strident opposition of the IOC, and particularly the IAAF and FINA, to the ‘New Games’. Thus, it proved that politics was the source of both the rise and the demise of the Games of the New Emerging Forces. Keywords: GANEFOOlympicsChinaIndonesiaEgyptCold War Acknowledgement Thanks to Julian Gornall-Thode for his editorial assistance. Notes 1. See Gitersos, ‘The Sporting Scramble for Africa’. 2. Rusli Lutan and Fan, ‘The Politicisation of Sport’, 436. 3. Olympic Council of Asia, ‘Jakarta 1962’. 4. Rusli Lutan and Fan, ‘The Politicisation of Sport’, 425; ‘Guanyu jiaqiang dui yazhou diqu tiyu wanglai gongzuo de qingshi [On the situation regarding our current work of strengthening Asian regional sport], September 1962, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People’s Republic of China Declassified Documents Reading Room, Beijing, China, computerised document number (MFACDN) 105-01085-07. 5. Rusli Lutan and Fan, ‘The Politicisation of Sport’, 431. 6. Ibid., 426. 7. Pauker, Ganefo I. 8. ‘Geng Biao fuwaizhang jiejian Yinni zhu Hua dashi Sukani tanhu jilu’, [A record of the conversation when Deputy Foreign Minister Geng Biao received the Indonesian Ambassador Sukarni] 20 February 1962, MFACDN 105-01168-06. 9. Rusli Lutan and Hong, ‘The Politicisation of Sport’, 431. 10. Yinni yaoqing wo canjia xinxing liliang yundonghui choubei huiyi he xinxing liliang yundonghui ji wofang fuzhao’, [Indonesia's invitation to the GANEFO preparatory meeting and to GANEFO and our response], Telegram from Jakarta Embassy (Jakarta) to Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Beijing (MFA), 5 April 1963, MFACDN 105-01833-02. 11. Ibid. The ‘Bandung Principles’ also known as Panchsheel or the ‘Five Principles of Peaceful Co-existence’ were agreed between India and China at the first Afro-Asian Conference, held in Bandung, Indonesia, in 1955. 12. Fan and Xiong, ‘Communist China’, 326. 13. ‘Guanyu wo zhichi zhaokai xinxing liliang yundonghui de fangzhen’, [Our policy regarding our support for holding the GANEFO], Jakarta to MFA, 25 February 1963, MFACDN 105-01169-01. 14. Ibid. 15. Pauker, Ganefo I, 6–7. 16. The Australian Olympic Committee, ‘1960 Rome’. 17. Pauker, Ganefo I, 7–8. 18. ‘Guanyu wo tiyuyundong weiyuanhui fuzhuren Huang Zhong tong Yinni tiyubuzhang Maladi, Yuenan tiyuwei mishu Wu Lun tanhua julu’, [A record of the conversation between Chinese Sports Commission Deputy Chairman Huang Zhong, Indonesian Sports Minister Maladi, and Vietnamese Sports Commission Secretary ‘Wu Lun’] 29 September 1964, MFACDN 105-016110-05, 12. 19. Pauker, Ganefo I, 8. 20. Ibid. 21. Ibid., 8–11. 22. Rusli Lutan and Fan, ‘The Politicisation of Sport’, 343; ‘Yilake canjia xinxing liliang yundonghui qingkuang’, [The situation of Iraq's attendance at GANEFO] 28 July 1963, MFACDN 107-00759-10. 23. Pauker, Ganefo I, 8–11. 24. ‘Guanyu xinyunhui fangzhen he dui Suxiu pohuai de duice’, [Our policy towards GANEFO and measures to counteract Soviet wrecking] 2 November 1963, op. cit. 25. Jakarta to MFA, ‘Sulian dui xinlianghui de taidu’ [‘The Soviet Attitude to GANEFO], 30 October 1963, MFACDN, 109-02544-01. 26. Ibid. 27. Ibid. 28. Sports Delegation in Jakarta to Beijing, 17 November 1963, ‘Guanyu xinxing liliang yundonghui qingkuang he geguo daibiaotuan qingkuang’ [The situation regarding GANEFO and the various delegations] MFACDN 105-01548-01. 29. Ibid. 30. Rusli Lutan and Fan, ‘The Politicisation of Sport’, 435. 31. ‘Guanyu xinyunhui fangzhen he dui Suxiu pohuai de duice’, [Our policy towards GANEFO and counter-measures against Soviet wrecking], 2 November 1963, op. cit. 32. ‘Guanyu xinxing liliang yundonghui qingkuang he geguo daibiaotuan qingkuang’ MFACDN 105-01548-01, 40–44. 33. This threat had already meant that most countries that sent official delegations, with the exception of China, Indonesia and Egypt, had sent sub-Olympic standard athletes to Jakarta. See Pauker, Ganefo I, 9, 24–25. 34. Guanyu xinxing liliang yundonghui qingkuang he geguo daibiaotuan qingkuang’ 17 November 1963, op. cit, 40–44. 35. Ibid. 36. Ibid. 37. Ibid.; Lutan and Fan, ‘The Politicisation of Sport’, 434. 38. Gitersos, ‘The Sporting Scramble for Africa’, 649. 39. ‘Guanyu wo dui xinxing liliang yundonghui de taidu wenti deng’, [Issues regarding our attitude towards GANEFO and other related matters] 17 November 1963, MFACDN 105-01170-05. 40. Ibid. 41. ‘Guanyu xinxing liliang yundonghui qingkuang he geguo daibiaotuan qingkuang’, 40–44, 17 November 1963, op. cit., 40-44 MFACDN 105-01548-01. 42. ‘Guanyu tong Sulaiman tan xinyunhui wenti de qingshi’, [The situation regarding my discussions with Suleiman about GANEFO issues] 25 November 1964, MFACDN 105-01611-08; Gitersos, ‘The Sporting Scramble for Africa’, 651. 43. ‘Guanyu dierjie xinxing liliang yundonghui wenti’, [Regarding the issue of the Second GANEFO] June to December 1964, MFACDN 105-01611-08. 44. Gitersos, ‘The Sporting Scramble for Africa’, 651. 45. Guanyu dierjie xinxing liliang yundonghui wenti’, op. cit. 46. Ibid. 47. Ibid. 48. Ibid., 655. 49. ‘Guanyu tong Sulaiman tan xinyunhui wenti de qingshi’, 25 November 1964, ‘Guanyu di’er jie xinxing liliang yundonghui wenti’, MFACDN 105-01611-08, op. cit. 50. ‘Maladi jianyi wu guo neibu hui zai YaFei huiyi hou zhaokai’, [Maladi suggests convening a meeting of five core countries after the Afro-Asian meeting] 23 December 1964, MFACDN 105-01611-08. 51. ‘Guanyu tong Sulaiman tan xinyunhui wenti de qingshi’, 25 November 1964, op. cit. 52. Ibid. 53. Espy, The Politics of the Olympic Games, 109. 54. Michael Leifer, ‘Cambodia Looks to China’, 27. 55. Clymer, Troubled Relations, 57. 56. Leifer, ‘Cambodia Looks to China’, 29. 57. Honneth, The Struggle for Recognition, 131–139. See also Linklater, Critical Theory, 185.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chris A. Connolly (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: