Key result
Chest-based Suunto Spartan Sport is the only valid HR monitor for mountain biking, showing ~1% error.
Why the study?
To assess the validity of several wearable heart rate monitors during mountain biking compared to the Polar H7 criterion device.
Do various wearable heart rate monitors provide valid heart rate measurements during mountain biking compared to a criterion chest strap?
Observational (n=20)
Do various wearable heart rate monitors provide valid heart rate measurements during mountain biking compared to a criterion chest strap?
Chest-based wireless ECG monitors provide the most valid heart rate tracking during mountain biking, whereas other wearable devices may lack accuracy.
This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
International Journal of Exercise Science 16(7): 1440-1450, 2023. Purpose: This study sought to assess the validity of several heart rate (HR) monitors in wearable technology during mountain biking (MTB), compared to the Polar H7® HR monitor, used as the criterion device. Methods: A total of 20 participants completed two MTB trials while wearing six HR monitors (5 test devices, 1 criterion). HR was recorded on a second-by-second basis for all devices analyzed. After data processing, validity measures were calculated, including 1. error analysis: mean absolute percentage errors (MAPE), mean absolute error (MAE), and mean error (ME), and 2. Correlation analysis: Lin’s concordance correlation coefficient (CCC) and Pearson’s correlation coefficient (r). Thresholds for validity were set at MAPE < 10% and CCC > 0.7. Results: The only device that was found to be valid during mountain biking was the Suunto Spartan Sport watch with accompanying HR monitor, with a MAPE of 0.66% and a CCC of 0.99 for the overall, combined data. Conclusion: If a person would like to track their HR during mountain biking, for pacing, training, or other reasons, the devices best able to produce valid results are chest-based, wireless electrocardiogram (ECG) monitors, secured by elastic straps to minimize the movement of the device, such as the Suunto chest-based HR monitor.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports validated chest-strap HR monitors for mountain biking accuracy; leaves open whether other wearables can be confirmed in larger studies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Carrier et al. (2023) conducted an observational in Mountain biking (n=20). Wearable heart rate monitors (5 test devices) vs. Polar H7 HR monitor (criterion device) was evaluated on Validity of heart rate monitors (MAPE < 10% and CCC > 0.7) (CCC 0.99). The Suunto Spartan Sport watch with chest-based HR monitor was the only valid device during mountain biking, demonstrating a mean absolute percentage error of 0.66% and a CCC of 0.99.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: