Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Contemporary work on citizenship questions the classic liberal version of citizenship as a legal status belonging to citizens of a particular nation-state. It recognizes the contingencies of political membership and the nature of citizenship as a mechanism for making claims upon different kinds of political communities, especially the state. Until recently, this was not a domain contemplated in mainstream development models. Even if issues such as governance have entered development agendas, the overall tone of the debate still focuses on technical rather than political questions. In this article, I argue that citizenship ideas can bring a particular politics and ethics into ‘development’, possible because of tensions between normative notions of citizenship and competing claims for more radical versions. I begin with an exploration of transformations in ‘development discourse’ that have brought questions of citizenship to centre stage. I then examine two aspects of citizenship, namely universality and quality, to argue that it is these in particular which might enable claims phrased in terms of citizenship to break through mainstream development discourses and articulate demands for deeper democracy and economic justice. Thus, through a focus on the quality of citizenship in specific contexts, it may be possible to radicalize the concept of ‘citizenship’ in development, both as an analytical category and as a means of promoting particular ethical values, different from those in the mainstream.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sian Lazar (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: