Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Humility of God:On a Disputed Question in Trinitarian Theology John R. Betz "Do you want to grasp the majesty of God? First grasp the humility of God. … When you grasp his humility, you will rise with him. —Augustine, Sermones1 The property of love is never to seek itself, to keep back nothing, but to give everything to the one it loves. —John of the Cross, Spiritual Canticle2 Among the more disputed theological questions of the last fifty years has been the question of whether the kenosis of the Son [End Page 769] of God in time (Phil 2:6–11) points to a kenosis within the immanent Trinity as its transcendent archetype. Hans Urs von Balthasar famously answered this question in the affirmative, and strikingly so: not only does the temporal kenosis of the Son reflect an eternal kenosis in the form of the Son's eternal humility and obedience with respect to the Father; this same phenomenal kenosis invites us speculatively to consider as its ultimate transcendental condition a primordial kenosis—an Ur-kenosis—that consists in the Father's eternally emptying himself in giving his Son all that he has and all that he is.3 For Balthasar, in other words, the Son's temporal kenosis is ultimately a reflection of a reflection, a mimetic enactment of the Father's own total gift of himself in begetting him. Contemporary Thomists, on the other hand, have tended to reject the notion of an intra-Trinitarian kenosis on the grounds that it introduces a category distinctive to the economy and bound up with the contingency of creation, into the divine nature. As Bruce Marshall, among the keenest of contemporary Thomists, puts it with his sights set on Balthasar and others: "Our understanding of how the three persons are one God must not be infiltrated or 'contaminated,' as it were, by terms and concepts that refer only to the economy."4 In other words, Marshall thinks, Balthasar ends up confusing theology proper (i.e., the doctrine of God) with what takes place in the economy (owing in part to the mischief he sees in Franz Anton Staudenmaier's distinction between the immanent and economic Trinity), and as a result ascribes things to God—kenosis, (infinite) distance between Father and Son, and even a kind of suffering—that cannot be reconciled with traditional divine attributes such as simplicity and impassibility.5 Others, such as Thomas Joseph White, O.P., Joshua Brotherton, and Guy Mansini, O.S.B., have voiced similar concerns, ranging from measured reservation to outright alarm. All of them, however, worry that [End Page 770] Balthasar not only "projects" words and concepts proper to creatures, such as "enrichment" and "surprise," into the divine life, but that his dramatic theology, which presents the persons of the Trinity as a veritable cast of characters, dramatis personae, willy-nilly turns Christianity into tritheism, and theology into mythology.6 Indeed, in the words of Mansini, perhaps the harshest of Balthasar's critics, "the Trinitarian kenosis of Balthasar destroys the Trinitarian theology of the Church."7 Such, then, is the status quaestionis: both Balthasar and the Thomists would seem to have theologically justifiable positions. They could even be said to have grounds for anathematizing one another. If the Thomists find Balthasar guilty of mythologizing theology and destroying Trinitarian theology, Balthasarians, in turn, could argue that the Thomists have not only failed to understand the meaning of the word revelation, but have turned the phenomenal glory of God (in his kenosis) into an unbelievably sterile system, a skeleton of propositions without spirit and life. Of course, these may be exaggerations; nevertheless, we would seem to be faced with a theological impasse comparable to that between the Dominicans and the Jesuits at the time of the de auxiliis controversy—an aporia not just between the apparent positions of Thomas and Balthasar (the quondam Jesuit), but one more broadly between the journals dedicated to their respective legacies, The Thomist and Communio. How, then, ought we proceed? Should we wait for another papal decree to bring an end to the dispute, which is highly unlikely given its speculative nature and far more pressing practical...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John R. Betz (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: