Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
On the Continuity of Caritas in Veritate Thomas Massaro S.J. EVEN EIGHT YEARS SINCE ITS RELEASE, Pope Benedict’s social encyclical Caritas in Veritate [hereafter, CV] continues to win admirers and to resist easy evaluation. Theologians, economists, and scholars of many related fields are still scrambling to come up with a balanced and complete assessment of its message and significance. This essay is a modest attempt to map out just a small corner of that territory from my own perspective as a social ethicist and close observer of Catholic social teaching. Assessing Benedict’s Social Encyclical Since its publication, CV has garnered much attention and prompted a great range of commentary. A first wave of coverage in the Catholic press and other popular media was followed by substantive treatments in more scholarly venues. For example, in the calendar year following its release, as many as seven major articles treating various aspects of the encyclical appeared in Theological Studies, the most prominent journal of Catholic theology in the United States. Symposia of articles on the encyclical have appeared in journals ranging from America magazine (see its November 30, 2009, issue featuring six short essays) to the Journal of Business Ethics (which ran a ten-article supplement in March of 2011), and several volumes of collected essays analyzing many aspects of the encyclical have recently appeared. I collect a small sampling of this literature in the notes and appended bibliography, but my selected list could be multiplied many times over. The timing and topic of CV surely accounts for a major share of the extraordinary interest in it. It was published eight short months [End Page 853] after the stunning collapse of the Lehman Brothers investment firm, perhaps the most dramatic moment in the string of events in the fall of 2008 that triggered a global economic recession. After months of news stories about the financial crisis, personal and corporate bankruptcies, skyrocketing unemployment rates, government bailouts, a foreclosure tsunami in the housing industry, stimulus packages, austerity measures and other reactions that we are still assessing, the world seemed hungry for a theological perspective on all this economic turmoil. Employing well over thirty thousand words, Pope Benedict produced one of the longest encyclicals ever. Some wags commented that there were actually several separate encyclicals nested inside the covers that bind the text of CV. No social encyclical had offered such a detailed account of the economic issues of the moment. Benedict delved into the complex tasks of diagnosis, prescription, and even prognosis regarding the moral and material health of the entire global economic system. Even many secular observers would confirm Benedict’s point that the 2008 economic crisis was best understood not as any kind of accidental bad luck, but as a moral crisis whose long and deep roots manifest themselves in faulty business practices, malfeasance of many varieties, ethically suspect behaviors, and objectionable public (as well as corporate) policies. Benedict was eager to connect these failings to deep anthropological errors and even metaphysical misunderstandings so that progress toward a more stable and just future would depend on correcting this range of abuses. In short, it is a challenging encyclical about both human nature and human experience, an ambitious vehicle for a religious leader to address timeless truths about the human condition, as well as crucial matters of the moment, such as current abuses of power in the international finance industry. Because Benedict has one eye on the current outward manifestations of this moral crisis and the other eye on its philosophical and theological roots, a single section of CV at once contains an appeal to uphold the “traditional principles of social ethics, like transparency, honesty and responsibility,” and a fervent plea to embrace “the principle of gratuitousness and the logic of gift as expressions of fraternity [which] can and must find their place within normal economic activity” (§36). In short, CV concerns the depths of our relationship with God, so it can be called a contribution to mystical theology. It proposes certain principles, so it is a contribution to moral theology [End Page 854] and social ethics. It addresses practical proposals to solve social problems of a specific moment in history...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thomas Massaro (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: