Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Recently, the world has witnessed a proliferation in the use of chatbots along with their legitimate applications in all fields of academics, commercialism, and entrepreneurs. Chatbots are smart tools which primarily use artificial intelligence (AI), automated rules, natural language processing (NLP), and machine learning (ML) to facilitate responses to all kinds of requests [1]. AI is the “ability of a digital computer or computer-controlled robot to perform tasks commonly associated with intelligent beings” [2]. Another upcoming technological innovation is the advent of generative AI (GAI), which yields assorted and diversified contents on a wider scale by curating the existing sources including, but not limited to, text, smart art, graphics, audio, and video [3]. Chatbots offer state-of-the-art perceptive interfaces in education, health, support, and several industrial fields. While using a chatbot, a client feeds a prompt in natural language, and the chatbot then provides a response through NLP within 1 s. This “prompt engineering” is a hallmark of all GAI-based materials, which can then be readily used by all clients in several disciplines [4]. As of today, there are divergent views about the proficiency of chatbots in medical education and research. Some journals have accepted different versions of chatbots including Bard, Bing, and ChatGPT as co-authors of scholarly write-ups [5]. In the scientific community, this approach has led to repercussions about the acceptance of chatbots as co-authors. Unfortunately, chatbots cannot replace real authors as they do not meet the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors authorship criteria for final approval of the manuscript before publication and to be accountable for all aspects of the scientific work for its accuracy or integrity [6]. Furthermore, apart from their technical developers, chatbots have no independent institutional affiliations. Foregoing in view, the Journal of Advances in Biomedical and Health Sciences has also adopted the policy of not recognizing chatbots as co-authors of the scholarly work. In addition, authors are required to attribute all materials generated by AI-driven chatbots in text and bibliography. ChatGPT, first released in November 2022, is freely accessible and spontaneously pulls responses from specific Internet sources, mostly without further input from the user. The ease of use and accessibility of ChatGPT has exponentially increased its usage in medical education. A large body of literature has reported that undergraduate and postgraduate medical and health students are liberally using ChatGPT to prepare university essays, projects, and scholarly articles [7]. Interestingly, if prompted, the AI system would insert accompanying references as well. In medical education, there is a dire need to develop meaningful curricular policies for a sustainable growth of AI systems, train faculty to deliver AI-powered education, foster inclusive data systems in health care, and conduct AI-based research while taking care of ethical concerns [8]. These potential advantages of chatbots in medical education are truly remarkable; however, medical educators and decision-makers should critically assess the ethical and technical implications of AI systems for their accurate and transparent usage. There are several risks and pitfalls in the use of chatbots and other AI-driven interfaces in health-care systems. In medical research, the chatbots developed by a biased dataset can generate inaccurate conclusions, thus resulting in harmful outcomes [9]. On a serious note, a chatbot tagged with a biased medical repository would incorrectly diagnose a medical condition and advise wrong management with potential harm to the patient. Similarly, chatbots programmed to disseminate targeted information about a medicine or procedure, for instance, may wrongly lead to the adoption of a harmful management algorithm. Finally, chatbots can also be manipulated to influence market research by overexaggerating and amplifying certain trends, which can lead to a harmful impact in the delivery of health-care systems [10]. In medical education, chatbots have the potential to replace human interactions and social expertise such as counseling and mental health. Resultantly, students may seek psychological and emotional assistance from chatbots instead of professional physicians. Such phenomenon may be detrimental to the development of social and soft skills of the learners. Despite the outlined caveats and shortcomings of chatbots, these AI/ML-powered tools carry a great promise in medical education and scientific research. A thorough review of the scientific policies, educational reforms for technology-enhanced learning, and faculty and student training toward digital literacy in a safe ethical environment will inevitably enrich the academic climate. Medical ethics courses with topics pertinent to patient privacy and confidentiality in the digital realm using AI tools will help mitigate the potential threats to the standard codes of medical professionalism. Medical institutions can work on cross-disciplinary integrated courses in digital health using augmented intelligence for the professional training of students from medicine, pharmacy, dental medicine, and all branches of health sciences. These training avenues in evidence-based medicine may embed modules on clinical decision-making systems with a critical review of the algorithmic biases in AI and ML. Financial support and sponsorship Not applicable. Conflict of interests SG is an editorial board member of the Advances in Biomedical and Health Sciences Journal. No conflict of interests declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Salman Yousuf Guraya (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: