Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose Islamic finance has received increasing scholarly attention as it expands globally. However, it faces increasing criticism for deviating from its original social and ethical objectives. This study aims to systematically examine these critiques, focusing on ethical, regulatory and operational issues within Islamic finance, using bibliometric methods to map trends in critical discourse. Design/methodology/approach This study uses a bibliometric approach to explore critical themes in Islamic economics and finance. An initial corpus of 1,014 documents was refined to 135 publications sourced from the Scopus database. Citation analysis was selected as the primary methodology over co-citation and bibliographic coupling due to its efficacy in tracing the evolution of arguments and capturing direct scholarly responses. This was followed by content analysis to interpret and classify the thematic focus of critiques. All data processing and visualization were conducted using R Studio and VOSviewer. Findings This study reveals a notable increase in scholarly critiques of Islamic finance since 2009 with a thematic shift from foundational topics to more specialized areas. Malaysia emerged as the prominent contributor while influential scholars, including Zubair Hasan and Muhammad Kabir Hassan, significantly shape this discourse, with the Journal of King Abdulaziz University: Islamic Economics serving as a primary publication outlet. Citation analysis revealed five main research clusters: general reforms, accounting standards, Islamic economics frameworks, participatory finance and the conceptualization of Islamic economics as a science. Current developments in Islamic economics and finance reflect many of the articulated criticisms, although further progress is still needed. Practical implications This research offers a foundational reference point for the critical discourse within Islamic finance, informing policy and institutional reforms in the sector. By identifying key contributors, influential works and emerging themes, the study provides practical guidance for stakeholders seeking to address ethical concerns and enhance the sector’s alignment with its core principles of social justice and economic inclusion. Originality/value This study presents a novel framework for systematically analyzing criticisms within the fields of Islamic economics and finance. It classifies critiques into distinct thematic clusters and uses citation analysis to delineate their interconnections. By integrating bibliometric and content analysis techniques, the research identifies emerging trends, key contributors and critical gaps in the extant literature.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Athief et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: