Key result
Adolescent conscientiousness predicted better adult psychological resources (β=0.23-0.29, p≤0.015), but was associated with higher metabolic syndrome scores in low SES black men (βint=-0.22, p=0.022).
Why the study?
It was unclear whether the benefits of conscientiousness on psychological resources and metabolic syndrome are amplified, disabled, or reversed in disadvantaged groups.
Does adolescent conscientiousness predict adult psychological resources and metabolic syndrome risk differently based on race and socioeconomic status in men?
Cohort (n=220)
Does adolescent conscientiousness predict adult psychological resources and metabolic syndrome risk differently based on race and socioeconomic status in men?
Adolescent conscientiousness predicts better adult psychological resources universally, but may be associated with higher metabolic syndrome risk in low-SES Black men, suggesting physiological costs of striving in disadvantaged groups.
Caution against broad conscientiousness interventions in disadvantaged youth; hypothesis-generating for race-SES moderators of personality-MetS links.
OBJECTIVE: Conscientiousness predicts better psychological resources as well as lower cardiovascular mortality and lower metabolic syndrome (MetS) risk. However, the benefits of conscientiousness might be amplified, disabled, or reversed in disadvantaged groups. This study is the first to test these competing hypotheses for prospective associations between adolescent conscientiousness and adult psychological resources and MetS. METHOD: Participants were 220 men (54.6% black) from the Pittsburgh Youth Study. Adolescent conscientiousness (M [SD] age = 16 [1]) was rated by participants and their parents. Adult (M [SD] age = 32 [1]) socioeconomic status (SES; occupation and education), psychological resources (composite of positive affect, purpose in life, optimism, self-mastery, and self-esteem), and MetS scores (glucose, lipids, waist circumference, and blood pressure) were measured. Hierarchical regressions were used to evaluate the association of conscientiousness with adult psychological resources and MetS scores, with testing of moderation by race and SES. RESULTS: Self- and parent-reported conscientiousness were associated with better psychological resources (βs = 0.23-0.29, ps ≤ .015), with no moderation by race or socioeconomic status. In the full sample, a three-way interaction of self-reported conscientiousness, race, and SES was obtained for MetS (β = 0.12, p = .093). Subgroup analysis indicated that self-reported conscientiousness was related to higher MetS scores in low SES black men (βint = -0.22, p = .022), but there was no comparable linear (βs ≤ 0.08, ps ≥ .50) or interaction (βs ≤ -0.13 ps ≥ .25) pattern in white men. CONCLUSIONS: Adolescent conscientiousness was beneficial for adult psychological resources, regardless of race or SES. However, there may be physiological costs of conscientiousness for black men from disadvantaged backgrounds.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Duggan et al. (2019) conducted a cohort in Metabolic syndrome and psychological resources (n=220). Adolescent conscientiousness was evaluated on Adult psychological resources and metabolic syndrome (MetS) scores (β 0.23-0.29, p=≤ .015). Adolescent conscientiousness predicted better adult psychological resources (β=0.23-0.29, p≤0.015), but was associated with higher metabolic syndrome scores in low SES black men (βint=-0.22, p=0.022).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: