Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Climate change poses many challenges to infrastructure in New York City. This chapter builds upon the work on climate change and critical infrastructure systems presented in the first and second New York Panel on Climate Change (NPCC) reports (NPCC, 2010, 2015), and provides new directions, updates, and considerations. Key concepts and definitions for resilience and vulnerability are found in Box 7.1. NPCC (2010) covered infrastructure by inventorying selected New York City facilities and their vulnerability to climate change. Vulnerabilities were described primarily in terms of outages and other disruptions, and covered a wide range of climate hazards, with a particular focus on exposure to sea level rise. NPCC2 (2015) did not have a separate chapter titled infrastructure, and infrastructure dimensions were distributed throughout the report. Resilience: Resilience is a core concept throughout the infrastructure and climate change theme. Resilience generally refers to the ability of systems, whether networked, interdependent, or independent, to return to some state after experiencing a disturbance and/or adopting processes that promote those readjustments. That state can either be the state prior to the disturbance or to a different state that can resist adverse effects of disturbances (Vale, 2014), resist change altogether, or prepare, respond, and recover from disturbances (NYC Mayor's Office of Recovery and Resiliency (ORR) 2018 Climate Resiliency Design Guidelines; City of New York, 2013). Resilience is often associated with vulnerability. Vulnerability: A review of the concept of vulnerability by Adger (2006: 268) defined vulnerability in the context of changing conditions or threats as "the state of susceptibility to harm from exposure to stresses associated with environmental and social change and from the absence of capacity to adapt" referencing both processes and outcomes. For infrastructure, aspects of vulnerability emphasized in this chapter are: its initial condition and its usage relative to its capacity, both of which influence the extent to which infrastructure is exposed to a threat and can resist or adapt to it maintaining at least its initial functions (Gallopín, 2006; Farmani and Butler, 2013; Zimmerman, 2016). In addition to building upon the previous work of the NPCC, many other New York City efforts are integrated in this chapter and others such as PlaNYC (City of New York, 2013), OneNYC (City of New York, 2015), the 1.5 Celsius Aligning NYC with the Paris Climate Agreement report (City of New York, September, 2017), the NYC Mayor's Office of Recovery & Resiliency Climate Resiliency Design Guidelines (NYC Mayor's ORR, April 2018) summarized in Box 7.2, and the NYC Office of the Mayor Mayor's Management Report (2017, 2018). New York State reports particularly following Hurricane Sandy (e.g., NYS, 2013) and U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) reports (U.S. DHS, 2013, 2015) are also key sources. NYC Climate Resiliency Design Guidelines: In April 2017, the NYC Mayor's ORR released a draft of its "Climate Resiliency Design Guidelines," which was finalized in 2018 (NYC Mayor's ORR, 2018). The Guidelines' purpose is to provide guidance on "how to use the range of climate projections in design" in order to promote resilience (NYC Mayor's ORR, 2018: 5) across the useful life of a facility in light of three climate elements: heat, precipitation, and sea level rise. The Guidelines indicate the need to coordinate with other guidance in connection with special funding and other requirements and considerations (NYC Mayor's ORR, 2018). Procedures are provided to select climate data, analyze risk, consider uncertainty, conduct sensitivity analyses, and identify and analyze design-related interventions depending on what the particular facility is, its useful life, and where it is located. This chapter focuses on infrastructure categories, typically referred to as "lifelines," for example, energy, transportation, telecommunications, water, and waste and sewers, that are considered "essential to the operation of most critical infrastructure sectors" (U.S. DHS, 2013: 17) and social infrastructure. Dependencies and interdependencies among infrastructures are another dimension addressed in addition to the individual sectors, and are defined in Box 7.3. The concept of dependencies and interdependencies among infrastructure sectors and between infrastructure and the economy and society was identified by Rinaldi et al. (2001), expanded in subsequent literature, and has increasingly been drawing the attention of infrastructure managers, infrastructure finance organizations, and disaster management agencies. Infrastructure interdependencies may not always have appeared to be a direct component of climate-related infrastructure concerns; however, the focus on interdependencies is emerging in the examples, scenarios, and guidelines being used to connect climate and infrastructure. According to Rinaldi et al. (2001), dependencies refer to a one-way relationship where one type of infrastructure depends on another but the reverse does not occur. Interdependencies connote at least a bi-directional relationship and can have a more complex structure when numerous infrastructure systems are involved. These concepts have since been carried forward into policy and planning documents, for example, into the sector-specific plans developed by the U.S. DHS for infrastructure (U.S. DHS, 2013; U.S. DHS, 2015). These documents and subsequent work have articulated various types of such interconnections involving, for example, spatial proximity, functional dependency, and information control, and the interconnections have formal properties that involve flows of people, goods, and information applicable to many infrastructure sectors (Rinaldi et al., 2001; U.S. DHS, 2015). These different types of interdependencies often occur simultaneously. The effects of these interconnections on system operations include what happens system-wide when a particular node (infrastructure component) or link (infrastructure route) upon which other systems rely becomes disabled. This partially explains why extreme events are a useful perspective for identifying infrastructure vulnerabilities. Metrics exist to characterize these relationships (which are addressed in Chapter 8: Indicators and Monitoring). Concepts and models for interdependencies have been developed and applied across a number of lifeline sectors, potentially applicable to climate change (Zimmerman et al., 2016, 2017, 2018; Zimmerman et al., 2017 and numerous references therein). Interdependencies have typically started with electric power, since it is used by practically all sectors either directly or indirectly, and electric power in turn relies on those other sectors. Electricity is used by the transportation sector for road-based systems to power lights, signals, and fuel pumps, and for rail-based systems to power signals, switches, and third rails and catenary lines to power trains (Zimmerman and Restrepo, 2009). Energy is vital to the water sector for the operation of pumps for those portions of the water supply system not operating by gravity and for intermittent pumping operations to dewater equipment that is flooded. Transportation in turn enables workers and supplies to be transported to facilities and services that are critical components of electric power and other infrastructures. Water is needed for power production and other processing functions, where they occur, as well as providing water for worker consumption. Telecommunications connect with all critical infrastructures for purposes of detecting system states and anomalies, controlling and managing infrastructure systems, and communication of information to deploy resources, and in turn relies on other infrastructure, particularly electric power, to function. Selected infrastructure properties that create potential vulnerabilities for infrastructure in the context of climate change are described in Box 7.4. Condition: The condition of infrastructure is assessed in many different ways, often constructed relative to or against needs and performance, and these dimensions of condition are interpreted or defined in many different ways depending on purpose, organizational mandates, and jurisdictions. For New York City, these are contained, for example, in the City of New York annual Mayor's Management Report (NYC Office of the Mayor, 2017, 2018), the OneNYC plan (City of New York, 2015), the National Academy of Sciences (2016) report that contained a New York City section, and other sector-specific documents. The American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) (2017) report card presented a number of measures for several of the city's infrastructure systems that reflect some potentially weakened conditions that could make parts of the system less resilient to the effects of climate change. Traditional condition measures, however, have not necessarily been linked directly to climate change, and Chapter 8: Indicators and Monitoring identifies some of the relationships that do exist. To make these linkages, inferences are required from underlying knowledge of conditions that potentially undermine the ability of infrastructure to withstand disruptions. Usage: Usages of infrastructures or consumption of infrastructure services varies considerably depending on the type of infrastructure. Generically, they can be in the form of rates of use, temporal patterns of use, and purpose of use. Most significant, regardless of how usage is measured, is the ratio or comparison of infrastructure usage to capacity, where capacity information is available, since it reflects potential impacts of new stresses on infrastructure designed and managed for different tolerances. This chapter on critical infrastructures is closely linked to Chapter 8, Indicators and Monitoring, and provides additional detailed references for that chapter. This chapter sets forth vulnerabilities of the critical infrastructure systems in New York City to key climate extremes, and Chapter 8 describes how to track those vulnerabilities and proposes the creation of the New York Climate Resiliency Indicators and Monitoring System to do so. In Section 7.2, infrastructure issues are examined with regard to the climate variables that are described in Chapters 2–4: (1) extreme heat, (2) cold snaps, (3) heavy downpours, (4) drought, (5) sea level rise and coastal flooding, and (6) extreme winds. This list of variables updates those that were identified in NPCC1 (NPCC, 2010). The impacts identified in this chapter provide the basis for and are directly linked to the infrastructure indicators and metrics in Chapter 8. In Section 7.3, key infrastructure vulnerabilities are addressed, first for individual infrastructures, with and without climate change in Sections 7.3.1 and 7.3.2 and then for infrastructure dependencies and interdependencies with and without climate change, respectively, in Sections 7.3.3 and 7.3.4. In Section 7.4, social infrastructure and related community issues are presented for two case studies that illustrate how infrastructure interfaces with communities, providing a model or benchmark for other cases. New finance and insurance mechanisms that have emerged to reduce vulnerability are introduced in Section 7.5. Section 7.6 briefly links infrastructure strategies to mitigation. In Section 7.7, conclusions and recommendations are presented that synthesize some of the major findings and suggest new directions. Appendices present background information for selected New York City infrastructure sectors (Appendix 7.A), a compendium of adaptation measures (Appendix 7.B), acknowledging the need to balance risk, cost, and uncertainty in implementation decisions, and the progress toward NYC's commitment to reduce GHG emissions 80% by 2050 (Appendix 7.C). The section on adaptation reflects part of a trend toward innovative urban transformation emerging as a new direction for infrastructure adaptation (Solecki et al., 2018). Different forms of stakeholder engagement were undertaken to provide inputs to this chapter. This overlapped to some extent with the stakeholder engagement process for the Indicators and Monitoring Workgroup, since that chapter also focused on infrastructure. One mechanism for stakeholder engagement was the New York City Climate Change Adaptation Task Force (CCATF). The city convened numerous city agencies and other organizations that oversee infrastructure through this venue covering the five lifeline infrastructure sectors in this report. A number of meetings in particular of the entire CCATF were attended by one or more of the coauthors of this chapter. These meetings were held on July 27, 2016, June 29, 2017, December 19, 2017, and July 26, 2018. Moreover, there were infrastructure-specific meetings, for example, several meetings of the CCATF Transportation Working Group that a representative of the infrastructure chapter attended. In addition, members of the infrastructure chapter participated in a roundtable organized by the Indicators and Monitoring Workgroup on March 9, 2016 that consisted of a number of city infrastructure agencies. A member of the infrastructure chapter team met routinely with members of the Indicators and Monitoring Workgroup and participated in their ongoing meetings with a couple of city agencies. Details of this process are described in Chapter 8, Indicators and Monitoring. Another mechanism consisted of informal engagement of members of infrastructure managers for specific portions of the work. The insurance and finance section authors, for example, took advantage of contacts with organizations relevant to that work. The staff of the NYC Mayor's Office of Recovery and Resiliency (ORR) provided important inputs on specific aspects of this chapter. Finally, informal contacts proved to be very valuable through venues such as professional society conferences and meetings (e.g., the ASCE) which afforded the opportunity not only to obtain information through formal presentations but as a basis for informal exchanges as well. The New York City "infrastructure-shed" extends well beyond the borders of the city's approximately 300 square mile area. The term "infrastructure-shed" has been used in the context of climate change by Rosenzweig et al. (2011) referring to the scope of the 2010 NPCC (2010). The city both affects and is affected by the region beyond its borders. This is particularly true of its infrastructure. Critical infrastructure is defined by the New York City CCATF and the NYC Panel on Climate Change as "systems and assets (excluding residential and commercial buildings, which are addressed by other efforts) that support activities that are vital to the city and for which the diminished functioning or destruction of such systems and assets would have a debilitating impact on public safety and/or economic security" (NPCC, 2009:8, footnote 3) The NPCC3 analyzes five key lifeline sectors plus social infrastructure systems that provide critical infrastructure to the New York metropolitan region: (1) energy, (2) transportation, (3) telecommunications, (4) water, (5) waste and sewers, and in addition (6) social infrastructure. The lifeline sectors as they pertain to NYC's infrastructure are described in more detail in Appendix 7.A. These lifeline sectors represent those that have been singled out by OneNYC (City of New York, 2015), PlaNYC SIRR (City of New York, 2013), and the National Infrastructure Advisory Council (NIAC) (2013), and are retained here for the purpose of consistency. Other areas of infrastructure not specifically singled out in OneNYC, such as banking and other financial institutions and solid waste management that have been used by other agencies, such as the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, are not included here. The buildings sector, which cuts across many of these others, are a separate report and inventory of GHG emissions that the city undertakes (City of New York, 2017) and are not included here, except with respect to how the buildings sector connects with other infrastructure. Each type of infrastructure has one or more technology dimensions or characteristics. Each technology has its own level of risk and resilience. New technologies are continually emerging that can change the nature of risk and resilience for each type of infrastructure. In its 2010 analysis, the first New York City Panel on Climate Change (NPCC1) presented a table that listed potential infrastructure impacts from climate extremes (NPCC, 2010). NPCC1 dealt extensively with the relationship between key climate change risk factors–higher mean temperature, changes in precipitation, and sea level rise–and their effects on energy, transportation, water supply, wastewater, solid waste, and communications infrastructure (NPCC, 2010). In NPCC3 (NPCC, 2015), those relationships are summarized, and the 2010 table is now updated, appearing in this chapter as Tables 7.1a through 7.1e to incorporate additional climate extremes (see also, Chapters 2–4) and impacts. Supplies: facilities that provide electric power for telecommunications (corresponds to electric power above) Anel, J.A., M. Fernandez-Gonzalez, X. Labadeira, et al. 2017. Impact of cold waves and heat waves on the energy production sector, Atmospere 8: 1–13. Bartos, M., M. Chester, N. Johnson, et al. 2016. Impacts of rising air temperatures on electric transmission ampacity and peak electricity load in the United States, Environ. Res. Lett. 11: 114008 City of New York. 2008. New York City DEP climate change program, assessment and action plan. New York, NY: NYCDEP. http://www.nyc.gov/html/dep/pdf/climate/climate_complete.pdf City of New York. 2013. Strategic initiative for rebuilding and resiliency (SIRR). A stronger, more resilient New York. http://www.nyc.gov/html/sirr/html/report/report.shtmlhttp://s-media.nyc.gov/agencies/sirr/SIRR_singles_Lo_res.pdf. City of New York. 2018. Progress report OneNYC 2018. https://onenyc.cityofnewyork.us/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/OneNYC_Progress_2018.pdf. Guenther, R. & J. Balbus. 2014. Primary protection: enhancing health care resilience for a changing climate. US Department of Health and Human Services. https://kresge.org/sites/default/files/Healthcare-Climate-Resilience-Guidance-HHS.pdf. Jacob, K., R. Blake, et al. 2010. Indicators and monitoring, Chapter 7. In Climate Change Adaptation in New York City: Building a Risk Management Response, New York City Panel on Climate Change 2010 Report. C. Rosenzweig & W. Solecki, Eds.: 127–141. Prepared for use by the New York City Climate Change Adaptation Task Force. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, Vol. 1196. New York, NY: NY Academy of Sciences. Kish, A. & G. Samavedam. 2013. Track buckling prevention: theory, safety concepts, and applications. U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Railroad Administration. Lloyd, E. & A. Licata. Undated circa 2015. One New York City: one water sustainable water management for New York City's people and environment. http://www.nyc.gov/html/dep/pdf/climate/one-nyc-one-water.pdf. New York City Mayor's Office of Recovery & Resiliency (ORR). 2018. Climate resiliency design guidelines. Version 2.0. New York, NY: NYC ORR. https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/orr/pdf/NYC_Climate_Resiliency_Design_Guidelines_v2-0.pdf. New York City Office of the Mayor. 2017. Mayor's management report 2017. http://www1.nyc.gov/assets/operations/downloads/pdf/mmr2017/2017_mmr.pdf. New York Panel on Climate Change. 2013. Climate risk information 2013 observations. Climate change projections, and maps. http://www.nyc.gov/html/planyc2030/downloads/pdf/npcc_climate_risk_information_2013_report.pdf. New York State 2100 Commission. 2013. Recommendations to improve the strength and resilience of the empire state's infrastructure. http://www.governor.ny.gov/sites/governor.ny.gov/files/archive/assets/documents/NYS2100.pdf. NYC Environmental Protection. 2013. NYC wastewater resiliency plan. Climate risk assessment and adaptation study. New York, NY: NYC DEP. http://www.nyc.gov/html/dep/pdf/climate/climate-plan-single-page.pdf. Rosenzweig, C., W. Solecki, A. DeGaetano, et al., Eds. 2011. Responding to climate change in New York State: the ClimAID integrated assessment for effective climate change adaptation. Technical Report. New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA), Albany, NY. R. et al. Energy sector vulnerability to climate a Energy U.S. Department of Federal Administration. 2011. and public transportation and climate change adaptation. U.S. Environmental Climate impacts on U.S. Environmental Climate impacts on transportation Zimmerman, R. & C. 2010. Infrastructure impacts and adaptation Chapter In Climate Change Adaptation in New York City: Building a Risk Management Response, New York City Panel on Climate Change 2010 Report. C. Rosenzweig & W. Solecki, Eds.: Prepared for use by the New York City Climate Change Adaptation Task Force. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, Vol. 1196. New York, NY: NY Academy of Sciences. In NPCC1 (NPCC, climate extremes, referred to as climate risk were to temperature, precipitation, and sea level rise. In extreme heat temperature, heavy precipitation, and sea level rise is with coastal In addition, cold snaps, drought, and extreme have been Tables 7.1a through 7.1e forth impacts that provide the basis for infrastructure indicators and metrics in Chapter 8. These climate extremes are described in more detail in The impacts listed in 7.1a through 7.1e are to be This section describes infrastructure vulnerabilities in the and climate. Section 7.3.1 infrastructure vulnerabilities of climate change individual infrastructures Section 7.3.2 climate change on these vulnerabilities. Section 7.3.3 how these individual infrastructure sectors are by dependencies and interdependencies without climate change and Section the dependencies and interdependencies with climate change. Energy and transportation infrastructure are but other lifeline sectors are also water and Each of these how individual infrastructure system can resist The first two and usage relative to critical related to vulnerability and are singled out for infrastructure is to it be less to withstand the condition of selected infrastructure in New York City and in some in the organizations work to the level of of infrastructure in the These include agencies at state and professional such as American Transportation and the and and In New York City, agencies include the New York City Office of Management in connection with the plan and other the New York City Mayor's Office of Recovery and Resiliency NYC Office of the infrastructure and and many of the city's community selected of infrastructure and often outages terms of number of affected and infrastructure in major of capacity in of State of for New York City (ASCE) by component as of components to plan for risk of design life or useful of or with water and and of facility The comparison between the extent of use of infrastructure and the capacity for which it has been designed and managed is a key of infrastructure capacity is the ability of infrastructure to withstand the impacts of additional stresses is potentially The ratio of use to capacity is often used as infrastructure for example, to capacity ratio for or consumption of electric power and water services and have been in the New York usage has in some been at least and in a comparison of usage against capacity is what is relevant for resilience. The transportation sector has generally in terms of of for road-based and 2018: and has some in the 2018: provides of some of these infrastructure usage that can be against capacity when such information on capacity becomes The previous identified some infrastructure vulnerabilities in the absence of climate change. In this section, some specific of climate change are introduced and related to selected infrastructure. The focus is primarily on vulnerabilities that in coastal areas to two climate (1) sea level rise and coastal and (2) These vulnerabilities to impacts in Tables of the components of the city's infrastructure assets and services are at risk from flooding, both directly and risk in terms of sea extreme flooding, and risk to areas that are not in areas but are to or Most vulnerabilities relevant to climate sea level rise pertain to and or potential exposure to sea level rise. 7.1a and indicate the vulnerability to for selected infrastructures in by of that following Hurricane The following in on the impacts of events on critical infrastructure sectors. to and Hurricane Sandy where selected critical infrastructure systems are in or with facilities in NYC SIRR (City of New York, 2013). The of NYC transportation systems that are or are for have been for some from the of and and studies of the of these facilities relative to sea A number of studies have identified for the most components of the city's the ClimAID for example, Rosenzweig et al. et al. Rosenzweig and the various components of the city's infrastructure various sea level Zimmerman and 2001; Zimmerman, and the lines and most to for example, the In addition, many other facilities are that are used for and of transportation infrastructure, as well as facilities for many electric power were for water and to of Selected were presented in Chapter of the 2010 NPCC report (NPCC, 2010). In addition to power other energy in particular were to coastal areas to have been in Hurricane A comparison of 7.1a and some of the to electric power from Hurricane Energy infrastructure in New York City power production and both and each different vulnerabilities depending on the lines are to and lines are to and water in The operation of and production equipment when
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zimmerman et al. (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: