Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Considerable research has been conducted evaluating yield relationships among crops in various rotations and cropping systems. To compare cropping systems of different lengths of rotation and with different crops, however, a common measurement is needed. This paper evaluates annual net return to land and unallocated resources (ANR) from various cropping systems containing sugarbeet ( Beta vulgaris L.), navy bean ( Phaseolus vulgaris L.), corn ( Zea mays L.), oat ( Avena sativa L.), and alfalfa ( Medicago sativa L.). Gross returns using representative crop prices are calculated for each cropping system for yield data from a 15‐yr cropping systems study conducted on a Misteguay silty clay soil in the Saginaw Valley of Michigan. Costs in 1991 dollars of agricultural inputs, machinery ownership, repairs, maintenance, fuel, and wages are used to calculate expenses. ANR is calculated by subtracting pre‐ and postharvest operating costs plus machinery ownership costs from gross income for two farm sizes and two sugarbeet prices. With sugarbeet priced at $36/ton, systems with the greatest proportion of sugarbeet and also including navy bean have the highest ANR. The relative ranking of a cropping system's ANR did not change appreciably when farm size increased from 600 to 1000 acres. A sensitivity analysis shows that sugarbeet priced at or below $18/ton caused the relative ranking of the systems to shift and navy bean to become a more dominant factor in the ANR of these systems. While short rotations for sugarbeet and navy bean production may result in lower crop yields, the high economic return of these crops is probably the major reason growers do not employ longer rotations. Research Question To compare several cropping systems containing different crops grown in rotations of different lengths requires development of a common measurement for all systems. In this study a common measurement “annual net return to land and unallocated resources” (ANR) is developed by subtracting costs for preharvest inputs, machinery ownership, labor and postharvest inputs from gross income. ANR is then used to compare cropping systems using yield data from a long‐term experiment. Literature Summary Cropping systems play an important role in maintaining yield, biological and economic stability of agricultural production due in part to the interruption of the life cycles of disease and other pests. In addition, diverse rotations distribute machinery and labor requirements over a greater portion of the season as well as lessening risks associated with fluctuations of yields and prices. Long‐term studies evaluating rotations or cropping systems are necessary to study the effects of crop yields. Integration of economic parameters makes it possible to compare the economic value of dissimilar cropping systems. Study Description This 15‐yr study was conducted in the Saginaw Valley of Michigan on a lake bed soil. Each crop was grown each year. General recommendations for fertilizers and pesticides were followed. A machinery selection model was used to select machinery complements to accomplish field operations common to the cropping methods used in the Saginaw Valley. This includes fall moldboard plowing, spring secondary tillage, growing crops in 30‐in. rows and two cultivations. Annual costs were then calculated for machinery ownership. Yield data from the 15‐yr study were used in this analysis. The 12 cropping systems are listed below: where: beet = sugarbeet and bean = navy bean. 2‐yr 3‐yr 4‐yr Corn‐beet Corn‐corn‐beet Corn‐corn‐corn‐beet Corn‐bean Corn‐bean‐beet Corn‐corn‐bean‐beet Bean‐beet Bean‐bean‐beet Corn‐bean‐bean‐beet Oat‐bean Oat‐bean‐beet Oat‐alfalfa‐bean‐beet Applied Question What is the effect of cropping system on yield? Yield of navy bean is generally better in 4‐yr rotations than in shorter rotations (Table ). Sugarbeet yielded more following navy bean than following corn. When corn follows corn in a rotation, yield is reduced by 11.9% compared with following navy bean or sugarbeet. What is the effect of cropping systems on net return to land and unallocated resources? For a 600‐acre farm and a sugarbeet price of $36/ton, ANR ranges from $392/acre for navy bean‐sugarbeet to $127/acre for oat‐navy bean (Table ). Systems containing sugarbeet had higher ANR than those that did not. The average ANR for 2‐yr systems containing sugarbeet is $355; for 3‐yr systems, $278; and‐ for 4‐yr systems, $173/acre. What happens to relative ranking of ANR for the systems when farm size is increased from 600 to 1000 acres? When farm size is increased for 600 to 1000 acres, the relative ranking of the cropping systems does not change appreciably. ANR increases an average of $16/acre for all systems. ANR for corn‐sugarbeet systems increased the least ($5/acre) due to greater machinery costs. The oat‐navy bean‐sugarbeet system increased the most ($32/acre), since machinery costs did not increase as much as for corn intensive systems. What happens to the relative ranking of cropping systems if sugarbeet prices decline? Since the gross return for sugarbeet is greater than for the other crops, we conducted an analysis to measure the effect of lower sugar prices on the ranking of these systems. There is no change in the ranking of the cropping systems until the sugarbeet price falls to $18/acre. Below this price, navy bean becomes a more dominant factor in the economic return from these systems. Average yield of crops grown in the Saginaw Valley cropping systems study. Position in the rotation Cropping system 1st 2nd 3rd 4th C‐SB 129 24.8 ‐‐ ‐‐ C‐NB 125 18.1 ‐‐ ‐‐ NB‐SB 16.3 25.3 ‐‐ ‐‐ O‐NB 80 18.4 ‐‐ ‐‐ C‐C‐SB 127 111 25.2 ‐‐ C‐NB‐SB 130 18.0 26.4 ‐‐ NB‐NB‐SB 15.3 16.5 26.4 ‐‐ O‐NB‐SB 83 18.5 25.2 ‐‐ C‐C‐C‐SB 125 113 105 24.7 C‐C‐NB‐SB 126 110 19.3 25.4 C‐NB‐NB‐SB 122 17.3 17.3 26.4 O‐A‐NB‐SB 85 2.84 19.5 26.8 C = corn: SB = sugarbeet; NB = navy bean; O = oat; A = alfalfa. Units: corn and oat = bu/acre; sugarbeet and alfalfa = tons/acre; navy bean = cwt/acre. Annual net return to land and unallocated resources (ANR) for two farm sizes with two sugarbeet prices in the Saginaw Valley Cropping Systems study. Sugarbeet price at $36/ton Sugarbeet price at $18/ton 600‐acre 1000‐acre 600‐acre 10
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Christenson et al. (1995) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: