Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Descriptions of 95 completed rapes and 41 attempted rapes which were committed by 72 men referred to a maximum security psychiatric institution were obtained from victim and police reports. Fifty of the victims received slight injury, fifteen were more seriously injured, and two were murdered. Rapists were more likely to complete the rape when the attack was conducted in an inside location, with a weapon, and not against a stranger. Victims were more likely to avoid being raped when they resisted, particularly when they screamed or yelled for help. There was no positive association between victim resistance and the probability of subsequent injury. Previous reports of resistance being related to victim injury may be because victims resist more strongly when they are being injured. Increasing attention has been focussed on the crime of rape over the past decade. Much of this attention has been in the form of advice to women on how rape might best be avoided. Unfortunately, however, this advice has often been contradictory (Quinsey, Marion, Upfold & Popple, in press; Storaska, 1975). Among the reasons for this discordant advice is the difficulty in comparing the effectiveness of various victim resistance strategies, partly because successful strategies are often undetectable. For example, a strategy implemented early in an attempted rape may remove the incident from any possible data set. If a woman is grabbed and immediately kicks her assailant and walks away, it may be unclear what the assailant's intent was. The more easily the intended victim deals with her assailant (i.e., the more effective the strategy) the less likely the act is to be reported. Despite their limitations, however, empirical studies of the outcome of identified rape attempts are the only means of providing an empirical base for advice to women on rape resistance methods. There have been a number of surveys based on police data which have examined women's rape resistance strategies. Bowker (1979) has summarized these studies and concluded that most women resist their attackers. Amir (1971) observed that 27% of the victims he studied resisted the attack and 18% physically fought back. Wright (1980) found that 70% of the victims in his study struggled and 16% fought. Both severe beatings and unsuccessful rapes were associated with victim fighting. Hursch (1977) concluded that in most successful instances of resistance, the This research was supported by Grant 847 from the Ontario Mental Health Foundation. We wish to thank G. Harris, M. Pruesse, and M. Rice for their comments on an earlier version of this paper. The first author is now at Institut Philippe Pinel de Montreal.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Quinsey et al. (1985) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: