Tradeoffs for a viral mutant with enhanced replication speed

RNA viruses exist as genetically heterogeneous populations due to high mutation rates and many of these mutations reduce fitness and/or replication speed. However, it is unknown whether mutations can increase replication speed of a virus already well adapted to replication in cultured cells. By sequentially passaging coxsackievirus B3 in cultured cells and collecting the very earliest progeny, we selected for increased replication speed. We found that a single mutation in a viral capsid protein, VP1-F106L, was sufficient for the fast-replication phenotype. Characterization of this mutant revealed quicker genome release during entry compared to wild-type virus, highlighting a previously unappreciated infection barrier. However, this mutation also reduced capsid stability in vitro and reduced replication and pathogenesis in mice. These results reveal a tradeoff between overall replication speed and fitness. Importantly, this approach— selecting for the earliest viral progeny—could be applied to a variety of viral systems and has the potential to reveal unanticipated inefficiencies in viral replication cycles. Significance Viruses have characteristic replication speeds within a given cell type. Many factors can slow the rate of viral replication, including attenuating mutations and host antiviral responses. However, it has been unclear whether it would be possible to “speed up” a virus that already replicates efficiently in a specific cell type. Here, we selected for a mutant coxsackievirus with enhanced replication speed by sequentially harvesting the very earliest progeny in multiple rounds of selection. A single mutation conferred the fast replication phenotype. While this mutant virus has enhanced replication in cultured cells due to faster genome uncoating, it was attenuated in mice. These results highlight selective pressures that shape viral populations in different environments.