Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Burn it all Down, or, Undisciplining Toward Just Reciprocities Priscilla Solis Ybarra (bio) Students who take classes with me learn by the end of the semester that if I ask them a question and they happened to have let their mind wander for a few seconds, they can safely answer "capitalism" or "colonization," and they will probably have offered the answer I was looking for. Why does U.S. culture insist on organizing power along a hierarchy? [End Page 34] Capitalism! Colonization! What causes the suffering of the character in this novel we're reading? Capitalism! Colonization! Of course we discuss finer details and dynamics, but my heart glows at their instinct to critique these oppressive systems. Another thing my students would probably tell you is that I consistently deride the categorization of knowledge into disciplines. At the same time, I insist they annotate their essays using the MLA Stylebook. Ironies. How do I explain my derision of the way they are asked to earn their diplomas by methodically accumulating credits from specific disciplinary fields? One thing we do is read Walter Benjamin's essay "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction" alongside an excerpt from Gloria Anzaldúa's Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza, the chapter "Tlilli, Tlapalli: The Path of the Red and Black Ink." Most literature students read Benjamin's essay sooner or later, I hope many also read Anzaldúa's book, and I'll venture to guess that not many read the two together. The juxtaposition of these two critics' views on art can be very fruitful. Both discuss the place and process of producing and sharing art in Western and non-Western contexts. Both lament the loss of an organic and contextualized understanding of art in the West. However, they each reach a different conclusion from these readings of art. While Benjamin mourns the contamination of the artistic process, Anzaldúa gives us a decolonial option beyond the Western approach to art.1 What we learn is ultimately about the poverty that the Western approach to art imposes. The Western approach to art rips the artwork from its cultural context, which ultimately means that it steals the meaning out of the art—what Benjamin calls the "aura."2 Benjamin tells this story along a linear history of ancient art that was contextualized within ceremony and place, and how Western culture gradually erodes this context until we get to the antiseptic setting of an art gallery and even beyond that into photographs of art hanging on a wall, films of sculptures sitting in an empty room. His ultimate warning is about how this all leads to manipulation of the proletariat and the production of fascist propaganda. Anzaldúa, too, laments this deterioration of relationship and context in Western art, but she doesn't indulge a linear history for this development. Anzaldúa explains that Western cultures behave differently toward works of art than do tribal cultures. … Tribal cultures keep art works in honored and sacred places in the home and elsewhere. … The works are treated not just as objects, but also as persons. The "witness" is a participant in the enactment of the work in a ritual, and not a member of the privileged classes.3 [End Page 35] She insists that the organic approach to art has existed all along within Indigenous and decolonial cultures that have been turning away from Western approaches to art, and many other aspects of being and imagining, for the lifespan of colonization. My students and I take heart from this argument. It gives us a place to inhabit apart from one of despair. We continue this thread by reading Kyle Whyte and Robin Wall Kimmerer, who similarly demonstrate the ways Native cultures integrate the everyday and the sacred, the creative and the scientific in their encounters with the impacts of colonization, climate change, and cultural continuity.4 Analogous to Benjamin's and Anzaldúa's analyses about art, the university rips the soul out of thought by breaking it up into categories, cordoning it off into separate departments and curricular structures, and creating competition between units. When we discipline knowledge, we miss the opportunity...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Priscilla Solis Ybarra (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: