Key result
Subjective echocardiographic assessment of right ventricular size and function showed slight to fair reliability and poor inter-rater agreement compared to quantitative MRI.
Why the study?
Does subjective echocardiographic assessment accurately estimate right ventricular size and systolic function compared to quantitative MRI in patients with right-sided congenital heart disease?
Observational (n=22)
Blinded to MRI results
Does subjective echocardiographic assessment accurately estimate right ventricular size and systolic function compared to quantitative MRI in patients with right-sided congenital heart disease?
Subjective echocardiographic assessment of right ventricular size and function has significant limitations and poor inter-rater reliability compared to MRI in patients with right heart disease.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Caution against subjective RV echo assessment in congenital disease; leaves open validation of quantitative echocardiographic methods versus MRI.
OBJECTIVE: The assessment of right ventricular (RV) size and function is important in the management of many patients with heart disease. Although magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is considered the gold standard for quantitation of ventricular volumes and systolic function, subjective assessment ("eyeball") by echocardiography is the modality most often used for the RV. The echocardiographic "eyeball" method of assessing RV size and systolic function was compared with quantitative MRI. DESIGN: Patients with right-sided congenital heart disease who underwent an echocardiogram within 6 months of MRI formed the study group. Four echocardiographers blinded to the MRI results reviewed the echocardiograms to subjectively assess RV size and systolic function. The reliability of an echocardiographer in accurately identifying a severely dilated RV and moderately to severely diminished RV systolic function was measured using the Kappa coefficient. Inter-rater agreement was also assessed using Kappa. RESULTS: The study group consisted of 22 patients aged 16.6 +/- 7.1 years, with interval between MRI and echocardiogram of 49 +/- 54 days. Using echocardiography, reliability for accurately identifying a severely dilated RV was "slight" with a prevalence-adjusted bias-adjusted Kappa (PABAK) of 0.25; and for identifying moderately to severely diminished RV systolic function was fair with a PABAK of 0.43. Inter-rater agreement analysis was poor for both with Kappas of 0.07 (P = .22) and 0.12 (P = .09), respectively. CONCLUSION: The usefulness of the echocardiographic "eyeball" method to estimate RV size and systolic function in patients with right heart disease has limitations when compared with MRI, specifically in regard to the variability between echocardiographers.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Puchalski et al. (2007) conducted an observational in Right-sided congenital heart disease (n=22). Echocardiographic "eyeball" method vs. Quantitative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was evaluated on Reliability for accurately identifying a severely dilated RV and moderately to severely diminished RV systolic function (PABAK 0.25 and 0.43, p=0.22 and 0.09). Subjective echocardiographic assessment of right ventricular size and function showed slight to fair reliability and poor inter-rater agreement compared to quantitative MRI.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: