Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Students need a moral compass to cope with the real ethical dilemmas they face from their earliest training. However, the best way to accomplish this objective is not clear, despite a mandate for such learning experiences in the standards for the accreditation of physician assistant (PA) programs. A structured Ethics Workup has been part of the Baylor College of Medicine PA Program medical ethics course since 2000. Where there is general ethical consensus the work-up helps students develop a management plan that is ethically justified and consistent with the consensus position. For controversial cases, the work-up teaches students how to make a well-reasoned ethically justified argument for a particular course of action. Seven faculty-facilitated small group sessions provide the context in which the students learn to use the work-up as a tool for case analysis and decision making. Two case vignettes are addressed in each group session, progressing in complexity from straightforward to more challenging. Students discuss the cases, argue their views based on logic, and defend their reasons for disagreement with the priorities among the appeals. Knowledge gain and capacity to decide when faced by an ethical dilemma is measured using a multiple-choice exam coupled with the written analysis of a case vignette using the Ethics Workup. Qualitative and quantitative feedback indicates that the Ethics Workup is a helpful tool for analyzing cases bolstered by quality small group case discussions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fasser et al. (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: