Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
All Earth’s major systems involve hydrologic processes. Water is also a unifying theme across the biological, geological, physical, and chemical sciences. Therefore, knowledge of water is crucial and water-related concepts are central components of the school science curriculum. The Next Generation Science Standards advocate teaching and learning about water as early as kindergarten. Scientific modeling is a science and engineering practice through which students are encouraged to develop, test, evaluate, and refine models of water-related phenomena. However, model-based teaching and learning about water, including evaporation and condensation, with early learners, presents an array of challenges. Little research has explored the ways in which elementary students evaluate their models and how instruction may support them to do so effectively. To address this gap, we investigated students’ evaluations of their own evaporation conceptual models in four third-grade classrooms (N = 81) in urban, suburban, and rural school settings within one region of a Midwestern State in the United States. We employed an embedded mixed methods design using student artifacts and classroom observations. Findings show that students were more effective in analyzing the process of evaporation as opposed to its underlying causal mechanisms. While observations of classroom instruction illustrated similar teaching practices across classrooms, some notable differences in Classroom 1 may help account for students’ evaluations of their evaporation models. These differences include: effective instructional strategies included highlighting real-world examples of the water cycle, revisiting student predictions, and peer discussion and revision of student models.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hulings et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: