Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The actual way in which our "mental health statistics" came to be what they are is not through the process of "detecting" a certain number of "cases" in a population as a result of "hospitalization." Instead, the figures which are published are reflections of many variables determined by different and complex social attitudes and socioeconomic practices. The most significant factor which is revealed by mental health figures is the degree of hospital utilization, and not hospital need. The remarkable successes which the public health people have achieved in the past in conquering many of our major health problems have left them with the time and resources to tackle new problems. They are now shifting their interest to the mental health field, and therefore represent one of psychiatry's most important potential allies. It behooves psychiatry to join forces with them. The new interdisciplinary frontier which is opening up, places on psychiatry's shoulders the responsibility of clarifying some of the misconceptions which are current. The true meaning of "mental health statistics" is one which only psychiatrists can interpret correctly. Like so much of what we say and write in psychiatric circles, they should not be taken at face value. The remarks made in this paper are designed to point the way toward a clarification of some of the contradictions which may not be apparent to public health workers. It is only fair to point out, however, that within the field of psychiatry there exists a point of view which would disagree with the above interpretations. This viewpoint is represented by those psychiatrists who see "mental illness" as an all-or-none pathological state comparable to contagious diseases, for example. It is largely from these psychiatrists that the data from which the new "epidemiological" studies are derived are being produced. When the public health worker seeks to interpret these data, he will be confronted with the dilemma of an old psychiatric controversy. We can only extend our sympathies to the poor investigator who finds himself innocently caught in the middle.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Charles E. Goshen (1961) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: