Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper argues that acquiring competencies in different approaches and procedures in qualitative or interpretative social research provides a strong foundation for case analysis in professional social work practice. When students of social work become familiar with such research and are encouraged to engage in their own supervised projects they develop skills for a circumspect and sensitive practice with clients. The paper reports on work with students of social work in Germany, which can be described as an attempt to help them to become self‐reflective ethnographers in their own affairs, of their own emergent social work practice. It spells out different phases of a process in which they learn to make their own practice strange. This process consists of developing different competencies in observing, analysing and writing, and requires a setting in which students' written observations and reflections can be shared and discussed by their peers in a critical, egalitarian and supportive manner. The author thinks that such a critical and self‐critical discourse which addresses professional issues in general, as well as the individual student's (or practioner's) experiences and reflections, can have important implications for the collective development of social work and its relationship with other professions. Keywords: social work trainingreflective practiceprofessional workethnographyqualitative researchgrounded theory Notes I am very grateful for helpful comments and suggestions by Prue Chamberlayne, Thomas Reim, Fritz Schütze and Tom Wengraf. The following observation is taken from a qualitative sociological study on social work counselling in families (Riemann, Citation2000). It is in the symbolic interactionist tradition of studying professions and work as developed by Everett Hughes (Hughes, Citation1984a) and Anselm Strauss (Strauss et al., Citation1985). With proper training, people can learn to ‘listen somewhat differently’. How social work can benefit from this approach should have become apparent in the discussion of the introductory example of this paper. A couple of years ago a student approached me wanting to write an essay about ‘causes of alcoholism’. When I asked her how her interest in this topic had developed, I learned that before entering university she had lived in an American Indian reservation for quite some time, where she had encountered biographical and collective demoralisation (due to the destruction of the indigenous culture). She often thought about her American Indian friends and their personal turmoil, but there was no space in the university to talk about these difficult experiences. Instead, she transformed these experiences into the problem of ‘the causes of alcoholism’, i.e. she had learned to devalue the overall context of her own experience and to adopt decontextualised abstract terms that she had come to think suitable for an academic environment. Colleagues of mine and I have introduced students to research in workshops designated as ‘Research Workshop for Biographical Analysis, Interaction Analysis and the Analysis of Social Worlds’ (Riemann & Schütze, Citation1987; Reim & Riemann, Citation1997). This is an arrangement in which students are assisted in conducting their own qualitative research projects. Since there are other aims and processes involved in this type of work, I will not discuss this arrangement in this paper. ‘Du’ (the informal term of address) is used in the German text. ‘Sie’ (the more formal and polite term of address) is used in the German text. I also find this tendency to self‐absorption in writings which have been referred to as ‘auto‐ethnography’ (cf. Emerson et al., Citation2001, p. 361; Murphy & Dingwall, Citation2001, p. 345; Reed‐Danahay, Citation2001, p. 407). The term ‘adjacency pair’ which has been coined and used by conversational analysts (cf. Schegloff & Sacks, Citation1973) refers to a single sequence of utterances by different speakers, in which the first utterance (the ‘first pair part’) constrains the second utterance (the ‘second pair part’) in some way, i.e. it makes a certain type of response expectable. Instances of such pair types are question–answer, greeting–greeting, offer–acceptance/refusal, etc. The following remarks are mainly based on my experience of working with undergraduate students in their third and fourth year of social work courses, who specialise in work with mentally ill patients and drug addicts. I have arranged together with a colleague (Jörg Wolstein), who is a psychiatrist, that this specialisation also includes a short work placement in the mental health field (either a couple of weeks in the semester break or a few hours per week over two semesters). By this time students have already been on a longer work placement of two semesters during their fourth and fifth semesters. These longer work placements can be situated in quite different fields of social work, not just mental health. I also encourage and supervise self‐reflective practice ethnographies during these longer placements when the students spend most of their time in social work agencies, only returning to the university for short ‘reflective’ breaks. The procedures of such ‘practice analysis seminars’ can be compared to the English practice of ‘institutional observation’ (Hinshelwood & Skogstad, Citation2000). ‘This open coding is done … by scrutinizing the fieldnote, interview, or other document very closely: line by line, or even word by word. The aim is to produce concepts that seem to fit the data. These concepts and their dimensions are as yet entirely provisional; but thinking about these results in a host of questions and equally provisional answers, immediately leads to further issues pertaining to conditions, strategies, interactions, and consequences. As the analyst moves to the next words, next lines, the process snowballs, with the quick surfacing of information bearing on the questions and hypotheses, and sometimes even possible crosscutting of dimensions. A single session with a single document can often astonish even the experienced researcher, especially when the document at first glance seemed not to promise much in the way of leads. The point is really that the potential is not so much in the document as in the relationship between it and the inquiring mind and training of a researcher who vigorously and imaginatively engages in the open coding’ (Strauss, Citation1987, p. 28). See the first section of this paper as to how this might happen.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gerhard Riemann (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: