Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
ABSTRACTSince 2014, Taiwanese society has used participatory budgeting (PB) in community-building. PB has also been an important strategy of the Ministry of Culture to promote Community-Building 3.0, deepen democracy, and promote participation. With case studies of PB in six communities, this study analyzes the relationships among deliberation, memory, and local consciousness. As a direct consequence of the adoption of PB, many communities have thus become the venue for deliberation and public participation, enabling community residents to experience the full process of PB. This study pays particular attention to the strategies and roles of heterogeneous actors in place-(re)making. The PB process can be employed not only to maintain, strengthen, and refresh existing local consciousness, but also to cause the modification, adjustment, and subversion of the existing local consciousness and even facilitate the emergence of a new local consciousness.KEYWORDS: Community developmentlocal consciousnessparticipatory budgetingcollective memorydeliberative democracy Disclosure statementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Biographical statementThe author is an associate professor at the Department of Sociology, National Taipei University. She is interested in collective memory, identity-remembering, political sociology, nationalism, cultural sociology, and cognitive sociology. Her work has been published in Qualitative Inquiry, Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism, Food, Culture, and Society, Symbolic Interaction, Nations and Nationalism, and Memory Studies.Notes1. In this study, the term "space" assumes two distinct interpretations contingent upon its contextual application. Firstly, it alludes to a broader spatial dimension. For instance, in the initial section of this article, "space" is underscored as a dimension often overlooked in numerous academic pursuits, thus necessitating heightened scrutiny within analytical frameworks. Moreover, "space" also serves as a juxtaposition to "place." In subsequent sections, "space" denotes a mere physical existence or location devoid of meanings ascribed by or for social actors. Consequently, in this connotation, it does not precipitate the emergence of a "place" sentiment.2. Deliberative democracy has been discussed by scholars and practitioners since the 1980s (Chen, Citation2006; Dryzek, Citation2000; Mansbridge, Citation1983). Unlike representative democracy (which usually causes adversaries and conflicts among camps), deliberative democracy serves as an alternative way to encourage laypeople to share their voices through a bottom-up approach to the decision-making process of social policy and highlights the values of equity, equality, inclusive, collaborative decision-making, and so on.3. Even if I strongly agree with this inference, this article believes that no sufficient cases exist to demonstrate how collective memory is constructed through space in the field of memory studies; this article can be used to supplement this argument.4. Many studies have noted the relationship between power and memory construction. More importantly, memory construction always occurs in the "present" and serves current needs (Schwartz, Citation1982).5. We should not observe the process of place-making from a static perspective; rather, it is a dynamic, continuous, and nonstop process. As a result, places continue to be making and remaking in various situations and conditions. An existing sense of place may still be defined and redefined according to the embedding social context and the social actions involved in it.6. Deliberations can open up the floor to those participants who hold alternative imaginations and ideas for public affairs or local issues because an ideal deliberation plan can provide a friendly environment for participants.7. "Deliberative community-building" is one of the important projects in the 3.0 version of community-building, which has been officially promoted in Taiwan since 1994. The Ministry of Culture sought to introduce the 3.0 version which emphasizes the deliberative democracy in order to further "deepening democracy and expanding participation."8. All communities names are pseudonyms. The interviewees were promised with the anonymity to avoid any unnecessary risks, hence in this article the pseudo names are adopted.9. The standard process of participatory budgeting can be divided into four steps: brainstorming, proposing projects, voting, and implementation (Ganuza & Baiocchi, Citation2012; Sintomer et al., Citation2012; Speer, Citation2012). The six communities included as cases in this article have all gone through these four steps. The discussion stage mentioned here is the brainstorming part (also known as resident assembly). Residents' assembly usually involves about 3.5 hours of discussion; groups of 8–10 participants discuss and share their own experiences and opinions, led by a facilitator who has received deliberation training to ensure that the spirit of public deliberation can be maintained. After the group discussion, each group explains their viewpoints to other groups. Finally, all participants vote for preferred projects put forward by the groups in order to set the priority, and the winning projects become candidate projects. After the resident assembly, the results of the brainstorming are refined through the proposal workshop to ensure that all candidate projects are promising and doable, with a certain degree of legality, enforceability, and innovation. The third stage allows more qualified laypeople to vote for candidate projects, while the final stage ensures that the selected projects that have the budget are implemented.10. Through interactions with residents, we learned that, although Guoling produces a variety of high-quality fruits, there has not beenmany areas and themes for tourists to stop and play. Tourists travel far to come to the community, yet there are not many attractions to keep tourists in the community and make consumptions. The earthen kiln and the baking courses are perceived as one possibility to keep tourists and a desired future community development. Moreover, the planned location of the bread kiln and courses is next to the story hall, so visitors can learn about the stories while baking.11. It is also possible that some candidate proposals that have the potential to become new traditions are not put forward during the discussion or are defeated and not favored during the voting stage. In addition, further observations are needed to examine whether successfully supported traditions are able to continue in the long run.12. This article uses "make," "invent," and "define" interchangeably to refer to assigning meanings and symbolic contents to space/place to facilitate the identification toward a community when discussing the influences of conducting PB.13. Place-inventing is a term proposed by this research to indicate deliberative works to foster residents' identification of their living space as a meaningful place/community.14. Collective memories can be reproduced in multiple ways. This article focuses on the invented traditions, but these traditions must be practiced and supported through more memory types. Due to limitations of length, this article does not discuss or analyze in detail what is covered by each program related to continuation, duplication, enhancement, refreshing, adjustment, and invention of local traditions. However, the elected proposals are indeed heterogeneous, such as the production and placement of statues, the planning and establishment of story halls, the writing of local story scripts and the performances on the stage, and the collection of old local photos.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hsin‐Yi Yeh (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: