Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In some senses, both science education and science communication share common goals. Both seek to educate, entertain and engage the public with and about science. Somewhat surprisingly, given their common goals, they have evolved as disparate academic fields where each pays little attention to the other.1 The purpose of this special issue, therefore, is an attempt some form of rapprochement—to contribute to building a better awareness of what each has to contribute to the other and the value of the scholarship conducted in both fields. Before attempting reconciliation, though, it is useful to point to several of the main differences between science education and science communication research traditions. One such difference is the emphasis that they give to each of those three aspects—educating, entertaining and engaging the public. Whereas the priority for science education is, not surprisingly—education—and entertainment and engagement are a helpful by product, for the field of science communication, it is engagement that is the priority. Another difference is the critical view that some science communication research adapts towards science and scientists, a result possibly of its journalistic and sociological foundations. Science education tends to position “what science says” and “how scientists do things” as the truth that frames the model for what students should learn. In contrast, many science communication researchers position “what science says” as only one of many types of potentially relevant knowledge and “how scientists do things” as an imperfect way of making sense of the world. Furthermore, the context of the formal (school) versus informal (media) environments has strongly affected the possible methods and the subjects of study. One simply cannot give a random sample of adult television viewers a one-hour test in a natural setting which changes the nature of the questions which can be addressed. In addition, compared to science education—a field of study that emerged in the 1950s, science communication is a relatively young field. One of the consequences of these differences is that the fields have distinct and separate emphases. For instance, one of the goals of science education is to educate the next generation of scientists – an aspect that concerns only those science communicators who work with young people, and then only to engage, stimulate and sustain interest in science. Given the significance of “interest” in sustaining engagement with the study of science (Maltese, Melki, & Wiebke, 2014, this is, nevertheless, an important contribution. Moreover, the field of science education has much that it could beg, borrow or steal to do a better job of sustaining student interest given the evidence of its failings (Bøe, Henriksen, Lyons, & Schreiner, 2011; Osborne, Simon, & Collins, 2003). By the end of the 12th grade, students should have gained sufficient knowledge of the practices, crosscutting concepts, and core ideas of science and engineering to engage in public discussions on science-related issues, to be critical consumers of scientific information related to their everyday lives (p24). One response to this demand has been a long list of initiatives to place the consideration and exploration of the role of science in society on the curriculum. The major stimulus, beginning perhaps with the publication of Rachel Carson's book, The Silent Spring (Carson, 1963), was the realization that science no longer offered simple technical solutions to the challenges facing humanity. Rather, it was also a source of problems—a thesis developed most cogently by Ulrich Beck in The Risk Society (Beck, 1992). In the light of such public discourse about science and its implications, any school science curriculum that chose to maintain a hermetic seal between science and society risked irrelevance. Science not only had applications but it also had implications. In the UK, this led to early initiatives such as Science and Society (Lewis, 1981) which was rapidly followed by the more pragmatic Science and Technology in Society (SATIS) (The Association for Science Education, 1986) and then Science for Public Understanding (Hunt & Millar, 2000). In the US, early initiatives were the Science Education for Public Understanding Project that begun in 1987 at Lawrence Hall. What these initiatives brought into being was a program of research that has explored how socio-scientific issues might be addressed in the classroom and the goals of such work (Kolstø, 2001; Levinson, 2006; Ratcliffe, 1997; Ratcliffe & Grace, 2003; Zeidler, 2003; Zeidler, Sadler, Simmons, & Howes, 2005). Others have gone further arguing that scientific literacy only has meaning as a concept of knowledge that is shared within a community which is orientated towards political action (Hodson, 2003; Roth & Calabrese Barton, 2004). Democracy functions by majority decision on major issues which, because of their complexity, require an increasing amount of background knowledge. For example, environmental and ethical issues cannot be the subject of informed debate unless young people possess certain scientific awareness. At the moment, decisions in this area are all too often based on subjective and emotional criteria, the majority lacking the general knowledge to make an informed choice. Clearly this does not mean turning everyone into a scientific expert, but enabling them to fulfill an enlightened role in making choices which affect their environment and to understand in broad terms the social implications of debates between experts. There is similarly a need to make everyone capable of making considered decisions as consumers (p24). The simplistic assumption often made within science education is that what matters is content knowledge—an assumption that was made too initially by those with an interest in science communication. Early work exposed the apparent ignorance of the public about basic scientific ideas (Durant, Evans, & Thomas, 1989; Miller, 1983), findings which were fitted into a deficit model of the public and an outcome which emphasized the imperative of communicating knowledge (Bodmer, 1985). The deficit model, rests on the assumption that the more scientific information the public has, the more its decisions will support or agree with the scientific consensus, and the more sympathy the public would have toward science (Brossard & Lewenstein, 2009). However, empirical support for these premises is at best mixed. Survey data shows that the relationship between scientific knowledge and attitudes toward science changes substantially between specific domains of science and technology (Allum, Sturgis, Tabourazi, & Brunton-Smith, 2008). Rather research would suggest that the variance in public attitudes on controversial socio-scientific issues is better explained by values, emotions, ideology, social identity, and trust in scientific and other institutions than by scientific knowledge per se. Furthermore, the validity of many of the surveys used to measure public's knowledge of science has been questioned. As many of us know, knowledge exists on a use-it or lose-it basis so asking individuals questions about specific pieces of domain-specific knowledge is, more often than not, likely to result in a display of ignorance (Stocklmayer & Bryant, 2014). As Kitcher (2010), Bromme & Goldman (2014) and also Feinstein in his paper for this special issue point out, the public knowledge of science will always be limited. Moreover, as Ryder (2001) has shown, in a detailed examination of the knowledge necessary to interpret science in the media, content knowledge is only one of six types of knowledge necessary to critically “read” reports about science. Required as well is a knowledge of the methods of collecting data, how data is interpreted, the role of modeling in science, the role of uncertainty in science, and how science is communicated in the public domain. Thus if science education is really to deliver on its goal of educating students to be able to make enlightened choices, it needs to broaden its conception of what aspects of scientific knowledge it should address. To give credit, where credit is due, the Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) are based on a set of 8 scientific practices that ask students explicitly to engage in many of the aspects in Ryder's list. Missing, however from the Framework for K-12 science education, which is the basis for the NGSS, is any specification of the procedural or epistemic knowledge of science that engaging in such practices should develop. In contrast, the latest PISA assessment framework (OECD, 2012), which defines scientific literacy in terms of the competencies to explain phenomena scientifically, evaluate and design scientific enquiry, and interpret data and evidence scientifically does attempt to define a body of procedural and epistemic knowledge necessary to undertake these practices. Thus, in that sense, the work of those in science communication has forced the agenda for science education making its narrow, domain-specific, content focus hard to justify. Notwithstanding these signs of convergence under the umbrella of “public engagement with science” (Feinstein, this issue), a central difference can be found in the implicit assumptions underlying the two research traditions. Science education makes the optimistic assumption that people who encounter science in their everyday life can, at least in theory, acquire the necessary knowledge to reach an informed, scientifically-based decision. In contrast, science communication finds people make meaning of the science they encounter in their lives using different narratives based on culturally relevant prior knowledge, that may or may not include science (Feinstein, 2012; Laslo, Baram-Tsabari, & Lewenstein, 2011). Furthermore, their ability to reach informed decision will be based not on a first hand evaluation of what is true? but on a second hand evaluation of “whom to trust?” (Bromme & Goldman, 2014). And if science education rejects the idea that science-related decisions should be based on trust, then the challenge such findings pose to science education is how should individuals be educated to judge what is true? For instance, one issue challenging the researchers at CERN has been the issue of whether the Large Hadron Collider could potentially create a black hole swallowing the Earth. How is a local French farmer to judge the truth of such claims? Given that few if any school science syllabi even mention black holes, it is very unlikely that this individual has any of the necessary scientific content knowledge. If so, what kind of knowledge would be helpful and how should this be explored in the formal science curriculum? Like so many issues that arise in the public domain—be they the threats posed by MMR vaccinations, GMO foods, or Climate Change, too many in the public are faced with a binary choice between denial or unquestioning acceptance. What can formal education do to reduce the epistemic distance between the expert and the lay individual? The message from the field of science communication is that the answer does not lie in more content knowledge but rather in attempts to engage the public in dialogue. What could unite both fields perhaps is a common vision of the role and importance of science in contemporary society. However, beyond fascination and awe, does either field have any sense of a grand narrative for science? Some may argue that in an era of post-modernity where the image of science has been sullied by the threats posed by technological advance, such a narrative is not needed or even counter productive. The goal of all science education or science communication should be to foster critical engagement rather than blind devotion. Nevertheless, we would contend that for all its flaws there needs to be a broader recognition within both fields of the cultural contribution that science has made to contemporary thought. Just as great literature has brought us a means of capturing and portraying the human condition, science has brought us a deep understanding of who we are and the material world that surrounds us. This it has achieved using six forms of reasoning—mathematical deduction which emerged 2000 years ago with the Greeks; experimental exploration which began in the 14th century and flourished in the Italian renaissance; hypothetical modeling to imagine a world which is too small to see or too large to imagine; categorization and classification of the world that surrounds us enabling biologists to identify distinct living species, chemists to identify elements and physicists to distinguish concepts such as heat and temperature; probabilistic and statistical thinking to identify patterns in nature and define the limits to certainty; and evolutionary accounts of the origins of species, the universe, continents, elements and more (Crombie, 1994; Hacking, 1992; make this point as both fields an important contribution to the work of their common we would do either fields share any sense of what that common might issue which is also in is as well as the the by this special issue to some sense of a common This special issue is of a view that there is too little between Science Education on K-12 education and in informal and Science on between the scientific community and other The of communication between the two fields the of shared and Science view science communication as a of informal science education, many science communication researchers at the very of science communication from an can be found on this point about the origins of this in is that in this issue, and a between the two research fields by about the needs of adult in to science education at school Another of this is that both fields the of the For example, the field of science communication has from the to a model of engaging the public with science. The the communication of public knowledge about science more as a between scientists and the society. science communication that science education is with the and its it is science who made the from an model of to a model long it was in the field of science communication. In this issue, Feinstein a of the and that could have been gained from a between the and research are to be to such as could be used to study science communication, basic communication concepts, such as could useful for science education In this issue, and how a context and the of to science communication can be in a that is to science Moreover, it is not only methods and that could be shared for The very basic concepts from the research on the and of science are used educating and scientists to engage in science that is of result is that much of this is with no goals in and assessment of the of these goals & Lewenstein, and make an exploration of how such science communication is by scientists and what make them more or likely to see its value and in such This set of very much an important attempt at between the two fields. goal was to a between the two of people they often share a common goal of communicating science, do not well with each For this issue, we a of and the are a of that In this Feinstein does the community a by us in with the we that as as the issues may to us many of them have the light of as who the of are to the of the What Feinstein has is a debate that a little than a years ago between often considered the of and What had to was the of is in any public debate the of knowledge that most of us have about the is very limited. Given how was it possible to the public in political As Feinstein out, this is a issue for science education that its place on the curriculum with the that it its students to scientifically and engage in such and such as Kitcher would argue that science education is in for that scientific literacy means most of the by it is to for at no in the of public school education has this much knowledge of science been or of school Kitcher it even more strongly that it is to that who have in the field can make decisions about technical If so, one might is the goal of enabling students to engage in critical evaluation of science either in the or as it them answer from who that the and on science on a community who have the to individual as in and community an individual does not need to about a as long as is to who is that the message for science education is that if we to support students to engage with science in their lives we them how to work Thus rather than the of attempting to educate student to be scientifically which as a too on an optimistic arguing that and those who are at how science education can support action a way of making education in science more relevant and enabling for its In this and contribute to the goal of the content and of science education to what need in to in a society. The the of the in the aspects of scientific that should possess using a scientists and researchers and scientists, of science, science and science This of two asking about needs in to curriculum means and a curriculum that would the needs of the However, is these this has and might be by from The second issue in to lay we have to are the on the needs of we on the of to their This potentially useful point between science communication research which at of with science related issues and science education research which how such should be conducted 2011). The by and with a the aspects by the of a of general and that are not related to the of science and technology or to work as of a The see them as and that lie at the of Moreover, the aspects related to attitudes and than to those to knowledge. The of such expert can be the background of science-related as well as the science education of of specific and a different on the science and society issue by at the scientists, rather than the of as those who have some to on a science communication of this issue is not to as and but as the context of public engagement with science, knowledge in that interest is a of science communication by scientists, but the emphasis from focus on information towards scientists to about science communication as a with the public. there are science institutions that from at to towards communication at scientists to foster with the in to reach who are not to science. a need for a in and of to the of research about which is to science communication and explored about make their science trust and that one to the that one about the public's and to with The is between what to the scientists to be ethical and make their message and what science communication research their message to with the The to this understanding of the value scientists might see in communication and the concerns they might have about its and in to support design and of this paper is that to in some of communication the scientists cannot be on as science the value in these they their to engage with the public were only more to reach the public the media, and at best to engage the public these attitudes is relevant to and other is to of the scientists as who could and should better knowledge, attitudes and in these In this and how a communicating a of research is and as it is and for a lay The is a of research at the of to are used to reduce and the research finds that the are often at than necessary for longer than The research is by the and the study in using how the research is “read” by the and then how it is into a form to be communicated to a The work on the of is the idea that any elements which how it is how this research is for its public and those choices are made by the By on certain the what individuals and argue that the of is too for the field of science education in that science the science they to their In this the how the concepts are initially in the publication using issues of uncertainty and the of to the importance and role of the then how certain of these frames are on by the such that the is with more emphasis given to some frames rather than such as the The paper then to at how these frames are and by one of the public who not study science beyond The work shows how this individual on his frames to interpret aspects of the detailed between the message of the and what might be the message by the lay the argue that is a where the message can really be The implications for science education are that we may need to students to identify the frames in a and to between them if they are to make sense of what the is to For science the argue that there is a need to a of frames to different of the if they to sustain a then this needs to be the The work to the field of science education on the role of and its significance in how meaning is to be from science For science where the concept of is what it is some into the nature of the of and the and nature of the frames that the public might The the findings to argue that the concept of is that has a to as between the two fields of science education and science communication. we both to one of the of this special issue who a ago in As a brought to the field of science education an that was both and had the of asking hard questions of community about the goals, and concepts that its In that one of his most was an examination of what is really by the concept of & 2003). This paper was the of a long of work beginning with an exploration of how science is communicated and the way in which people meaning from such & whether the goal of is and more how literature can be used within science education work is in his & was who that the first of an is to ask the hard questions that had that was of his in this special can only that what is offered would have his
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Baram‐Tsabari et al. (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: