Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Abstract Background/Objectives: The Gough’s F-K index is one of the most effective validity indicators of the MMPI-2 (a reference instrument in the forensic setting) for discriminating between simulated and genuine profiles. However, the reported effect sizes are so large that they may be attributable, to some extent, to experimental design artifacts. Therefore, this study aimed to estimate the true effect size of the F-K Index in discriminating between simulated and genuine profiles, as well as the effect of the comparison group type (in-study control group vs. combined control group). Method: A total of 54 studies were identified, from which 77 effect sizes were obtained. A psychometric random-effects meta-analysis was performed on experimental effect sizes. Results: The results showed an average true effect size of δ = 3.67, which was positive, very large, significant, and generalizable for the in-study control group comparison condition. Likewise, the results showed an average true effect size of δ = 2.43, which was positive, very large, significant, and generalizable for the combined control group comparison condition. Comparatively, the results indicated a significantly larger effect for the in-study control group comparison condition. Discussion: The true effect found using data from the original studies (i.e., comparison with the in-study control group) is so large (> 99th percentile of all possible values) that it is undoubtedly overestimated. A source of this overestimation is the use of a non-normative control group configuration. The implications of these findings for the forensic evaluation of simulation in the forensic context are discussed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pouso et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: