Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This issue of Health Libraries Review marks a new tenancy for this column in the shape of the LINC Health Panel Research Working Party and concentrates on the topic of obtaining research funding. Numerous books exist to point professionals from all sectors towards the successful securing of research funds 1-3 and a CD-ROM has recently served to augment the resource list. 4 The exhaustive approach of such resources, however, can often be demoralizing to the relatively inexperienced researcher who may be led to think that securing research funding is more a Holy Grail than a realizable goal. Arguably it would be more helpful, as well as being a good deal more heartening, to concentrate on a few key and achievable tenets. This column focuses on the practice rather than the theory of submitting proposals and attempts to distil some of the lessons learnt from nine proposals received in response to the LINC Health Panel’s Research in the Workplace (RIWA) call. Although the principles outlined below are based on the specifics of this award they are readily transferable to other submissions. 1 November 1999 saw the announcement of the winners of the inaugural Research in the Workplace Award (RIWA)—Michelle Kirkwood and Anne Wilson from Glasgow Royal Infirmary. The successful research proposal involved a Delphi study to determine research priorities and the corresponding evidence base in North Glasgow hospitals. The Delphi technique is currently enjoying a high profile following an excellent study and follow-up article by Maureen Dwyer. 5 Maureen showcased her study at last year’s Health Libraries Group Research for the Uninitiated Study Day, an event that also included presentations and practical sessions on obtaining funding. . This does not mean that health information research projects should all be double-blind randomized controlled trials. Evaluation research can command a variety of study designs, but does require that these go beyond a mere survey of users, nonusers or potential users of library services. It is a feature of good library practice to continuously evaluate services and so it is difficult to justify this as a discrete area for additional research expenditure. Optimally, quantitative research will outline a hypothesis, will involve some form of comparison (such as before vs. after or sites with an intervention vs. sites without) and will collect some baseline data, associated with the hypothesis, over and above routine service data. . Good research will be applicable to a wider context. This might simply be to similar libraries to the one being investigated or might be by extrapolation to other types of library. In some cases it will be the methods rather than the results that will most readily be transferable. If several alternative methods or study populations are available when designing the study it is well to consider which of these might be of the broadest applicability. . It might seem unnecessary to encourage librarians to conduct a literature search on their research topic but the standard of supporting literature to the majority of proposals was very poor. Citing government policy documents may help to establish the importance of the topic but will do little to support the feasibility of the project itself. A funding body will want to be reassured that you have learnt from the experiences of others rather than having to learn everything from your own mistakes at their expense. Even if a topic has not previously been investigated there will be certain references that will be useful in ensuring the rigour of your methodology. . Although this principle may seem very closely connected to that mentioned above, data collection instruments such as forms, questionnaires and surveys provide a specific instance where duplication should be avoided. Use of an existing instrument, or adapting it to meet your specific need, can yield a number of concrete advantages. First, it may reduce the time required to pilot your data collection methods. Second, as other professions such as health economists have discovered, it may provide you with an already validated instrument. Finally, it may allow comparison with other studies that use the same instrument, either across all findings or between specific questions. . Those proposals that demonstrated a team-based approach, that indicated the applicants had identified the skills required for their task and that, more importantly, had taken steps to address any skills deficits, generated greater confidence that the proposed project would be completed satisfactorily. This criterion was also linked to the desire of the award assessors to create a profile for the successful project beyond the domain traditionally occupied by the health information worker. Participation by a number of different disciplines across a Trust or similar organization was an indicator, albeit crude, that the topic being researched is an organizational priority and not merely a personal hobby horse. . Although it is clearly outside the realms of most health information workers to be familiar with concepts such as power calculations and Type I and Type II errors it is true that a would-be researcher should give some thought as to who is going to be involved in the research project—the study population. How many people will be included? How representative are they? Are there any ways in which they are untypical of a more general ‘real world’ population? What is the likelihood that the sample will exclude some very important characteristics that will be present in the population to whom it is intended to apply the results? For example, a study on search styles that bases its design on findings from two or three librarians might be of limited applicability if all those librarians happen, by chance, to have the same search style. Extending the initial sample to a larger group might yield a more accurate picture of the relative frequency of different search styles and yet still allow the researcher to focus, for practical reasons, on those styles that have been found to be most common. . Why do they want to commission research? What possible ‘spin’ could they put on your project were it to prove successful? Funding bodies will obviously wish to gain some mileage from the research project, both at the time the award is announced and, more importantly, when the results become available. In the instance of the RIWA the purpose of the Award was to encourage health information practitioners to acquire research skills. Particular attention was therefore paid to each proposal for any information on how the Award might benefit the professional development of the participating librarian or information officer with respect to acquisition of research skills or expertise. Where such information was not available it was assumed that the outcome would simply be completion of the project itself with no by-products from the research process. Proposals that lacked this professional development perspective were therefore seen to be less attractive. . There are two aspects to this particular principle. At its most straightforward level it requires a suggested strategy for dissemination of study results, including identification of a target journal for a subsequent publication, wherever possible. However, consider who will be reading about your research. In the case of the RIWA Award the equivalent to the ‘man on the Clapham omnibus’ would be the subscriber to Health Libraries Review. This requires that a well-designed research study addressing issues of common concern to most health information practitioners is preferred over an otherwise scientifically rigorous experiment that tackles an esoteric issue of interest to a specialist few. So, for example, the successful proposal has the potential to inform the practice not only of those involved in support to research and development in nursing at a local level but also of any librarian involved in mechanisms of prioritization within any healthcare organization. It is hoped that the eight principles outlined briefly above will assist future would-be researchers in the crafting and targeting of successful research proposals. Each of the nine proposals was independently reviewed by three peer reviewers, John Van Loo (Health Sciences Libraries, University of Sheffield), Christine Urquhart (University of Aberystwyth) and Andrew Booth (School of Health and Related Research, University of Sheffield). All the reviewers are experienced in assessing proposals and the review was carried out blind to the identities of the investigators. Formal criteria, in addition to the considerations mentioned above, were applied from a scoring instrument designed by LIRG, the public sector library research group, and consensus was reached following discussion. There was a high degree of agreement between the three reviewers with three of the top four projects being agreed unanimously. Individualized feedback on validity, feasibility and applicability was provided for all applicants, successful and unsuccessful. Evidence-based librarianship, a movement to get research findings into information practice, requires good quality studies that address questions of relevance to practitioners. A number of initiatives are currently underway to improve the ability of health information professionals to interpret, and act upon, the findings of well-conducted research and these will be reviewed in the next research column. In contrast, the Research in the Workplace Award targets the producers’ end of the research process attempting to stimulate good quality research in a workplace setting. As health librarians improve in their ability to appraise existing research they will develop associated expertise in designing new and improved research studies. It is hoped that the above principles will help to consolidate this aim. The RIWA award has been a learning opportunity for members of the LINC Health Panel Research Working Party as well as for the applicants to this inaugural research funding scheme. In particular, the multiplicity of sponsors; the Health Libraries Group, UMSLG, UHSL, Libraries for Nursing and IFM Healthcare, has caused unforeseen problems with regard to co-ordinating receipt and subsequent payment of the total amount. Subsequent years of the Award will aim to see improvements in the quality of applications, more professional research fund administration and greater publicity concerning the availability, and the subsequent allocation, of the research funds. In the meantime the LINC Health Panel Research Working Party will continue to work towards the stimulation of a research-aware culture among health information professionals, both in the UK and overseas.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Andrew Booth (2000) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: